Debate Rounds (4)
Abortion: the intentional ending of a pregnancy
I will be arguing that:
1. Abortion is in violation of human rights, and goes against the original hippocratic oath.
2. Doctors aren't always right about the physical condition and life expectancy of a baby before birth
3. The medical community is pressuring women to have abortions if there is any complications
1) Prohibition of a choice is taking our ability to make our own decisions away.
2) Accidental childbirth can result in having to give up personal goals.
3) Abortion is not the murder of a person, as the fetus is not developed enough to feel the pain
It is violation of a number of articles in the Declaration of Human Rights.
All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.
You cannot be born free if you are dead before you are born.
Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person.
All of which are withdrawn from an aborted fetus.
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
Everyone has the right to recognition everywhere as a person before the law.
In your outline you said "Abortion is not the murder of a person, as the fetus is not developed enough to feel the pain." As a human, even a very small one, they have the right to recognition as a person.
I'd also like to bring up the Hippocratic Oath. Since the original oath many changes have been made, with many doctor's swearing different oaths.
A section from the Hippocratic Oath reads:
I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect. Similarly I will not give to a woman an abortive remedy.
In ancient Greek times people understood that it wasn't appropriate to give an abortive remedy (ie. perform an abortion) to a woman. The word "Similarly" is used. This suggests that the killing of a baby is equal to helping kill themselves.
Here's the thing though, it hasn't been born freely, so it does not have equal rights. If it cannot speak, cannot feel, we are doing nothing wrong. Unless, of course, the abortion happens after the 3rd trimester, which never happens.
Here's a scenerio where Pro-Life screws a good person over. Although used often, it fits perfectly.
Betty is No. 1 in her whole school. One day, she is walking home from school. She is attacked a brutally raped. Betty finds out later that she is pregnent. If she had a choice, she wouldn't have to go through the pain and suffering of a pregnency, and possible caring after a child. Her life suffers in the pro-life option. Her rank drops due to bullying, having to take time off of school for the birth, and later caring for the child. She could put it up for adoption, but she has gone through so much pain for this baby she didn't even really want, so to just give it up is not an option to her. But even if she did, she's already dropped her grades, she can no longer play sports because she blimped up during the pregnency, and kids tease her. But since she didn't, she can no longer go to college and, as awful as it may seem, many people find having a child as a turn off. So now she is a single mother who is about to be fired from her job at Mcdonalds because she has to bring the baby with, and it cries. All of this could have ended with the choice to cause an abortion to something that wasn't even supposed to exist and, unlike Betty, will not feel the pain of all of it ending. Fast forward 5 years, Betty has died from suicide, since her life was turned around so badly. The kid now jumps from foster home to foster home. With a father either in hiding, or locked up, or dead. And a mother who has commited suicide by this kid indirectly.
Now the kid has a crappy life, and the mother HAD a crappy life. All because it's 'inhumane' to abort a fetus before it even has a conscience.
That quote refers to abortion as a deadly drug, but it's not close. It stops the baby from developing, and is not the murder of a human.. Also, no matter what you believe in, the baby will be in a better place.
Also, when dictionaries define 'abortion', they say that it is the termination, or destruction of a fetus. Never death. This is because it's not a death, but in fact is just stopping the birth.
In the ancient Greek times, abortions were not as safe as they are today. Quite actually, the killing of the baby was practically killing themselves back them. That leaves me to believe the analogy means it is actually helping them kill themselves.
I looked at two different answers to why women have abortions.
The first one was simpler, with less specific categories.
93% -Personal Choice or Inconvenience
4% -Mother's Health
2.5% -Baby's Health
0.5% Rape or Incest
The second one had more categories, but showed similar results.
27% -Not Ready / Poor Timing
25% -Can't Afford a Baby
20% -Finished with Childbearing
9% -Relationship Issues
8% -Lack of Maturity
4% -School or Career Concerns
4% -Fetal Health Concerns
3% -Parental Health Concerns
As it turns out the fetus can feel pain quite early on. At 3 weeks, the fetus nervous system is virtually complete. So it can feel pain. Ultrasounds from during abortions sometimes show babies screaming from inside the womb.
Doctors can't always tell the physical conditional of a baby before it's born. There was a baby who the doctors said that would be born without a brain. The parents went through with the pregnancy and the child lived for 4 years. But it wasn't 4 years instead of 70, it was 4 years instead of none. Another person I know, the baby's lungs weren't developing properly. The doctors said that the baby would be sickly. Be is alive, and just like any other baby. What I mean by this is that the doctors can't tell the future, they can give a good guess, but they aren't always right. Another person I know has had 3 or 4 abortions, because she was told that it could kill her. After that she later had a child. Both she and her child are fine.
IncognitoTurtle forfeited this round.
SomeoneWhoIsAlive forfeited this round.
IncognitoTurtle forfeited this round.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by lannan13 2 years ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||4||0|
Reasons for voting decision: Pro forfeited more and wasn't able to uphold BOP.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.