The Instigator
Con (against)
0 Points
The Contender
Pro (for)
0 Points

Alternatives to Public Schooling Should be banned.

Do you like this debate?NoYes+0
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point
Started: 10/1/2013 Category: Education
Updated: 3 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 823 times Debate No: 38365
Debate Rounds (4)
Comments (3)
Votes (0)




First round to accept!!!
I will be taking the side that states that alternatives to public schools should NOT be banned. As pro, you would say that they should be banned. Good luck and first to accept takes it.


The practice of home schooling has essentially been around since the dawn of time. Parents and guardians have always took it upon themselves to teach the younger generation the knowledge that they have received through their many years of experience. But we live in a different world now, governments have recognized the massive need for an educated youth and have provided public school systems to insure that vital knowledge gets passed on, also I would say that young children need to communicate with their peers have friends e.t.c it is very important aspect of humans life that we need to consider. Some children are very shy and it is hard for them to make new friends that is way parents allow them to study at home! But in my opinion it is not right young children need to learn how to solve their problems by their own! So that is why I think that home education should be banned!
Debate Round No. 1


I didn't talk about home schooling. Just alternative schooling options to public education. This first round, I will address private schools, which I have attended for 11 years.

1. Individual Attention

Most parents want their children to have as much personal attention as possible. After all, you spent enormous amounts of time nurturing them when they were infants. If you can make it happen, you want them receiving as much individual attention as possible in the preschool and primary years.

If you send your child to a private school she will be in a small class in most schools. Independent schools have class sizes in a range of 10-15 students. Parochial schools have slightly larger class sizes which are typically in the 20-25 student range. With those kinds of low student to teacher ratios a teacher can give each student the individual attention she deserves.

The other factor to consider is that discipline is not usually a problem in private schools. There are two reasons why: most students are in private school because they want to learn and, secondly, the codes of conduct by which most private schools operate, are enforced. In other words if a student misbehaves or breaks the rules, there will be consequences.

2. Parental Involvement
Private schools expect parents to be actively involved in their child's education. The concept of a three way partnership is an important part of the way most private schools work. Naturally the degree of participation and involvement will probably be greater if you have a child in preschool or elementary grades than if you are the parent of a child away at boarding school.

What kind of involvement are we talking about? That depends on you and the amount of time which you can devote to helping out. That also depends on your talents and experience. The important thing to do is to observe and see where you can fit in. If the school needs a gifted organizer to run the annual auction, then help out as a committee member for a year or two before offering to take on that major responsibility. If your daughter's teacher asks you to help chaperon a field trip, that's an opportunity to show what a great team player you are.

3. Academic Issues
Most private schools do not have to teach to a test. As a result, they can afford to focus on teaching your child how to think, as opposed to teaching her what to think. That's an important concept to understand. In many public schools poor test scores can mean less money for the school, negative publicity and even the chance that a teacher could be reviewed unfavorably.

Private schools don't have those pressures of public accountability. They must meet or usually exceed state curriculum and graduation minimum requirements. But they are accountable only to their client. If the school does not achieve the desired results, parents will find a school which does.

Because private school classes are small, your child cannot hide in the back of the class. If she does not understand a math concept, the teacher will probably discover that pretty quickly. He can address that learning issue on the spot, rather than waiting weeks or months to fix it.

Many schools use a teacher guided approach to learning so that students discover that learning is exciting and full of possibilities. Since private schools offer all kinds of educational methods and approaches ranging from very traditional to very progressive, it is up to you to choose a school whose approach and philosophy meshes best with your own aims and objectives.

4. A Balanced Program
Ideally you want your child to have a balanced program in school. A balanced program can be defined as equal parts academics, sports and extracurricular activities. Most private schools try to achieve that kind of balanced program. In private school everybody takes part in sports. Wednesdays in many schools are a half day of formal classes and a half day of sports. At boarding schools, after classes end on Saturday mornings everybody heads out for sports.

Sports programs and facilities vary greatly from school to school. Some of the more established boarding schools have sport programs and facilities which are finer than those at many colleges and universities. Regardless of the scope of a school's sports program, what is really important is that every child is required to participate in some athletic activity.

Extracurricular activities are the third component in a balanced program. Like the compulsory sports students must participate in some extracurricular activity.

As you begin to explore school websites, review the sports and extracurricular activities as carefully as you review the academic curriculum. Make sure that your child's interests and needs are properly met. You should also note that intramural sports and most extracurricular activities are coached or supervised by a faculty member. That's part of the job description in most private schools. Seeing your math teacher coaching the soccer team and sharing the same passion for the sport that you have, well, that makes a huge impression on a young mind. In a private school teachers have the opportunity to be exemplars in many things.

5. Religious Teaching
Public schools have to keep religion out of the classroom. Private schools can teach religion or ignore it according to the mission and philosophy of the particular school. If you are a devout Lutheran, there are hundreds of Lutheran owned and operated schools in which your Lutheran beliefs and practices will not only be respected but they will be taught on a daily basis. The same is true of all the other religious denominations. All you have to do is find a school which meets your needs.



karina_kimep forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 2
This round has not been posted yet.
This round has not been posted yet.
Debate Round No. 3


I stick to my argument. I add this though about my opponents paragraph about home schooling:

Sandra Day-O'Connor was home schooled and was a very successful modern woman in politics.

Home schooling brings a child closer to his family and gives more time to grow relationships with parents or relatives.

Home schooling associations help with child interaction at different age groups.

The government is rarely correct on any matter.



karina_kimep forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 4
3 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 3 records.
Posted by michaeltaffe3 3 years ago
Okay then Gordontrek, I will.
Posted by Gordontrek 3 years ago
I believe that Con should address homeschooling. Is it not an alternative to public schooling? And a highly successful one at that?
Posted by Sitara 3 years ago
Post another debate with the correct title. I came here because I thought you were opposing schooling options. LOL.
No votes have been placed for this debate.