Does every American have the RIGHT to Food, Water and Shelter?
Debate Rounds (4)
First Round: acceptance
Second Round: opening arguments only
Third & Fourth Round: arguments and rebuttals
I would like to ask Con: What proof do you have that Con is real? If he is real, how do you know that food, water, and shelter aren't rights he gave us?
Dictionary.com says that a right is "a just claim or title, whether legal, prescriptive, or moral". So really, the question is "Does every American have the title to Food, Water, and Shelter?"
Another question that I would like Con to answer: If we have the natural right to life (which means our life can't be taken by the government), then if I were to say we have the right/title to food, water, and shelter, then that means the government can't take it away.
Then, Con says that slavery is immoral. Irrelevant entirely.
The only reason I did rebuttals instead of opening arguments was because Con posted his opening arguments early.
Yes, you have the God-given right to life, but that does not mean that you have a right to the fruit of my labor to maintain that life.
So where is this defense of the existence of this right? And who do you say should be foced to pay for your fool, water and clothing?
To have the right to food, water, and shelter is different than having someone else pay for yours. As I mentioned before, a right represents something not that is given, but something that can't be taken away.
Next, I will make note that in 1776, yes, the nation was founded under god. However, according to the Constitution of the United States of America, the church is not over the state. So "god-given rights" are irrelevant to this debate.
Con is right that I haven't yet defended the existence of this right. I will now.
It comes down to the Ninth Amendment of our American Constitution. This states that there are more rights than listed, and they cannot be violated. I am quite sure that not having your food, water, and shelter stolen or taken by the government is definitely one of them.
But if you mean that you having the right to fool, water and shelter means only that the state cannot take them away from you, which is to say the state cannot prevent you from eating, drinking or building yourself a home on your own land, then you and I are in full agreement.
CodeFunny forfeited this round.
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.