Iceman would beat Spider-Man in combat!
Debate Rounds (3)
Peter beats Bobby by 2 in intelligence and 1 in strength. Their speed and fighting skills are the same. Bobby beats Peter by 1 in durability, and by 4in energy projection. [1, 2]
From their base stats alone, it's difficult to place a winner. Bobby, as a mutant, may beat Peter overwhelmingly in the energy projection category, but Peter's fought beings with energy projection powers before, and won. Peter's also got technological items he made due to his intelligence that level the playing field. It could be also argued that Peter's better strength is canceled out by Bobby's better durability.
However, Peter has two damning advantages. First, he is much more intelligent. With everything else about the same, intelligence makes all the difference. Secondly, Peter is more popular. From that alone, the writers would be more likely to have him win.
Thus, Spider-Man would win in a battle.
Iceman also has the ability to create clones of himself out of ice. He can therefore be able to beat up Spidey from several different places as much, if he wills Spider-Man to live that long.
It was confirmed that Bobby was suppressing his powers for a short period of time  and still has his powers. Although Spider-Man is very clever, his intellect cannot save him from being frozen in an instant. Iceman has the ability to transform himself into virtually indestructible ice, making it impossible for someone like Spider-Man to injure him. Iceman is also able to make his body temp 0 Kelvin, so if Spidey were to touch him, he'd freeze. The only thing stopping Iceman from killing Spider-Man is his morals.
Even putting that aside, Peter has previously won against a foe literally made out of fire- Firelord- who, is "the humanoid equivalent of a miniature sun." with nothing but his wits  . If he can beat a foe who "can burn through any Earthly substance", a man who does the opposite would be a cinch. Firelord also happens to have power grid rankings much higher than that of Iceman .
Thus, in sum, for both meta and in-universe reasons, Peter would not lose against Bobby.
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.