If Solipsism is believed to be real and true, then theism must also be true and real.
My ego would prefer an opponent (being myself), without the capability to overcome my premise. Will I defeat myself in this debate? Only I can know the answer.
I accept your debate and look forward to your arguments.
Solipsism - 1. Philosophy The theory that the self is the only thing that can be known and verified.
2. The view that the self is the only reality.
Theism - Belief in the existence of a god or gods, especially belief in a personal God as creator and ruler of the world.
I observe and understand solipsism to be a philosophical theory relating one's own reality, mere existence, being equated to a complex construct, created within one's own imagination. Essentially, solipsism abides by three presuppositions,
"These are: (a) What I know most certainly are the contents of my own mind - my thoughts, experiences, affective states, and so forth.; (b) There is no conceptual or logically necessary link between the mental and the physical. For example, there is no necessary link between the occurrence of certain conscious experiences or mental states and the "possession" and behavioral dispositions of a body of a particular kind; and (c) The experiences of a given person are necessarily private to that person."
The theist must believe in the existence of one or more Gods. "God" can take many forms, God can exist anywhere or in anything, as God is omnipresent. "Thus, when considering and evaluating theism, we are normally engaged in considering and evaluating a variety of interconnected beliefs, ideas, and assertions." However, such predetermined beliefs, ideas, and assertions may not be the proper practice for a theist solipsist individual. "Theism does not depend upon how one arrives at their belief."
To be religious is to believe in a particular set of principles, however, theism is belief in the existence of a God or Gods (real or imagined). All the many numerous world religions, along with the many religious moral and ethical principles, have all been created in the mind of the solipsist. Theological concepts in Christianity, the Muslim culture, Greek Gods, the very idea of Heaven and Hell, has been created and fully developed in the clear imagination of the solipsist.
"I suppose that one reason I have always detested religion is its sly tendency to insinuate the idea that the universe is designed with 'you' in mind or, even worse, that there is a divine plan into which one fits whether one knows it or not. This kind of modesty is too arrogant for me."
R13; Christopher Hitchens, Hitch-22: A Memoir
Solipsism makes the argument that "The Universe", as you perceive it to be, is designed and produced by one's self. Elevating ones status to that of their own Universe's Creator. The solipsist philosophical viewpoint argues that oneself is the only verifiable reality. The only world which the solipsist knows and understands, is a universe in which "self", is the creator and ruler of their own imagined Universe.
If I am but one solipsist, creating such an amazing, interesting, mysterious world that seems so vivid, where have I gained such immense knowledge and such a tremendous imagination? Have I innately learned so many languages and cultures? Why would I imagine pain and suffering for so many people throughout the world? In reality, the reality I have created resembles nothing like a blend of Disney and Wonka Land, as I would have imagined, I would have imagined as a solipsist. The solipsist theory requires that the individual must live, and solely exists, as the God of their own Universe.
"When a solipsist dies ... everything goes with him."
R13; David Foster Wallace, Consider the Lobster and Other Essays
Either the solipsist individual must be God or,"If reality cannot be proven to be more than a construct of consciousness, then in order for the external world to exist independently of my consciousness, it must exist, in full, in some consciousness that is at a higher level than mine. In this case, I am a figment of this higher consciousness"s imagination, as are all the people and beings that I encounter." Solipsism is dependent upon theism, as the solipsist must be the God of their own Universe or a "God" must have created the solipsist.
Therefore, in order for the solipsist theory to be true and real, then the theism must also be true and real, in order to maintain the universe and existence of the solipsist "self".
(Apologies if I'm wrong, but I'm working under the assumption that R2 is for arguments and R3 is for rebuttals.)
All gods, from almost all cultures, meet, to varying degrees, most or all of those qualifications. If solipsism is true, then the solipsist, as far as he/she can verify, only meets one, and even that to an unimpressive degree (as the solipsist is unable to actively control the universe). Just because one is a creator, doesn’t mean one is a god.
Once again I return to the scientist analogy. Let’s say that the scientist was able to create another universe. If they were unable to control the universe at will, still able to be killed in that universe, were able to be harmed by anyone, couldn’t know everything going on, and wasn’t supernatural, it hardly seems fit to call them a god, thus making theism accurate for said universe.
We then see in turn that the solipsist is unable to control the universe at will, able to be killed in the universe, able to be harmed by anyone, can’t know everything going on, and isn’t supernatural. This last problem deserves its own sub-contention.
The Problem with the supernatural
The issue with theism in general is that it rests on the supernatural.
I quote James Orr,
“If God is a reality, the whole universe rests on a supernatural basis. A supernatural presence pervades it; a supernatural presence sustains it.”
This sense of “supernatural” is the issue. It’s a vague term that generally means outside of nature. The trouble with this is that if the world did not actually exist and the only thing that did exist was the solipsist, then the solipsist would be the only natural entity. The solipsist would not be not supernatural. But the only natural entity.
I hope you enjoyed my arguments, I await yours.
The Blue Arcanist
2PartyFarce forfeited this round.
TheBlueWizard forfeited this round.