The Instigator
poshselena300
Con (against)
Tied
0 Points
The Contender
Canadian-In-Florida
Pro (for)
Tied
0 Points

Mom is Pulling me and my sisters' hair!

Do you like this debate?NoYes+0
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point
Started: 1/21/2013 Category: News
Updated: 4 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 3,520 times Debate No: 29415
Debate Rounds (3)
Comments (7)
Votes (0)

 

poshselena300

Con

So my mom told me to rinse a plate out and I said that it was her plate and she pulled my hair! Should moms do that?!
Canadian-In-Florida

Pro

So, your mom pulls your hair..........do you think it is abuse? If so, do as one of the members posted in a comment said and call the child abuse hotline, or contact family services. If you don't think it's actually abuse then rinse your plate and move on.

What it comes down to is a reasonable level of physical interaction involved in punishment of a child by a parent. While pulling hair is a bit odd for a parent, if she didn't rip out half your scalp, throw you against a wall or to the floor by your hair, or otherwise do more than what could constitute as a similar action to a spanking or something of that nature, then it was odd but not a problem. If she did injure you, or cause true physical harm other than a momentary pain, then you're in the realm of considering abuse of some sort.

The argument over physical punishment for children has been going on for years, but ultimately it is only something really debated in recent times. The APA did a study on the effectiveness of corporal punishment and it came to the findings that when administered seldomly, with limitations between punishment and abuse, and while the parent is in a non-aggressive mood, then it can be an effective means of discipline (http://www.apa.org...). Of course there are fine lines here, but that is always a means of contention.

Now, the next issue lies in the fact that if I am to assume correct age from your profile, you are 16 years old. While the study above states that corporal punishment can be effective with proper use, it is also true that it is minimally effective, if at all, after the age of 9-10 (http://www.psychpage.com...). Because of this, you now have a much different issue at hand.

The overall problem is that what your mother did may not have been harsh enough to constitute crossing the line of punishment/abuse, or maybe it was, but regardless of if it crossed that line, you're now at the age that physical reprimand no longer bears a significant amount of weight in developing discipline. Your mind has developed to a point that you can discuss things and hash things out verbally.

Ultimately, from the reaction you stated, and I'm going to guess that it was a heated moment of sorts, as with many teenagers whether they like to admit it or not, the situation was probably an instinctual or overly emotionally flared moment. Both parties probably escalated too far, and you should address this with your mother, one on one. If you really go injured and thrown aross a room or something, then consider contacting someone, but if she just pulled it and it hurt a bit, it was probably just an escalation that shouldn't have happened. While I'm not advocating that parents should just go around escalating events with their children like this, I think that if you're at an age where you're able to come to a site like this and open up a debate on child abuse to discuss it, you can just as well sit down with your mother and talk this out. If she is unwilling AND continues to pull your hair and do things like this then you should consider contacting someone, but if this was an isolated incident and up to now you've never approached your mother about things like this then just do that. You need to be assertive and stand up for yourself and confront the issue with her directly. It will utimately show her that you're maturing and able to stand up for yourself and thatyou won't take behavior from her like that. In doing this remain calm, don't yell or berate or argue. Simply sit down and talk. If she tries to escalate, hold your ground, talk assertively but not aggressively. Emphasize, don't yell. Do that and you'll be fine. If it doesn't stop, try again or contact someone.
Debate Round No. 1
poshselena300

Con

The problem is is that it's not just me getting my hair pulled it's my other sisters too! I can't hit her back because that would just be flat out wrong! And seriously no weave or nothing she pulled my hair and started hitting my nose to my mouth. Then I went to my dad and told him that she as pulling my hair. When I came back she made me wash a pot load of dishes and while I was doing so she kept calling me a "snitch" or a "Tattle Tale Twit". That's when I decided that I would leave the kitchen and go downstairs because their was no way I could wash the dishes while she as doing that. I came back about 10 minutes later and noticed she washed for me. Not to sound lazy by the way. When I went to the side of the table she came in the kitchen and said in a grouchy voice to my sister that "I don't want you butting in" Then my mom charged at her and my sister started to run,but my mom grabbed her shirt dropping 3 chairs and pulled her back by her shirt and pulled her hair then slapped her also on the nose and mouth. I just stood there in shock. Then my mom turned around and gave me a dirty look. Also the chairs DID NOT fall on her. I picked them up after they dropped.
Canadian-In-Florida

Pro

As multiple comments say, if shes actually hitting you like that and acting like that and your dad is doing nothing then call someone. That's not behaviour that should be expected from a five year old, so coming from a parent that's wrong. If what you are saying is an accurate representation of the facts then call child services or the police.

There is nothing really left to debate on this topic. This really shouldn't have become a debate but I took it cause comments were not satisfactorily addressing the issue. Now with further information there is reasonable cause for calls to someone on this issue. I would now urge you to ignore round three and I will do the same and simply follow the advice given by myself and the commenters.

I wish you the best in this unfortunate situation.
Debate Round No. 2
poshselena300

Con

poshselena300 forfeited this round.
Canadian-In-Florida

Pro

Canadian-In-Florida forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 3
7 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 7 records.
Posted by Deadlykris 4 years ago
Deadlykris
Based on your most recent argument I recommend you talk to the police.
Posted by poshselena300 4 years ago
poshselena300
@mak-zie: Why not? I hope that answered it..
@phantom: Really?! Pull her hair back? My mom is British she would call the police on me!
Posted by 1Devilsadvocate 4 years ago
1Devilsadvocate
Child Abuse Hotline: 1-800-342-3720. TDD/TTY: 1-800-638-5163
Posted by 1Devilsadvocate 4 years ago
1Devilsadvocate
http://www.childhelp.org...

National child abuse hotline - 1800 - 422 - 4453
Posted by phantom 4 years ago
phantom
Pull her hair back!
Posted by Mak-zie 4 years ago
Mak-zie
So many questions here....First of all, why did you decide to put this on debate.org?
Posted by famer 4 years ago
famer
.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................i........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
No votes have been placed for this debate.