The Instigator
Pro (for)
0 Points
The Contender
Con (against)
0 Points

Public colleges should be fully funded by the government

Do you like this debate?NoYes+1
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point
Started: 9/12/2012 Category: Education
Updated: 5 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 2,170 times Debate No: 25573
Debate Rounds (4)
Comments (4)
Votes (0)




Public colleges should be fully funded by the government. First post is acceptance.



First time debater here, not really sure on the rules, so sorry if I say or do something out of line.

As reported by, in 2010 the average cost of going to school for a year is as follows.
Public University (4 years): $27,967 (per year)
Private University (4 years): $40,476 (per year)

This adds up to a total of (4 years)
Public University: $111,868
Private University: $161,904

Another statistic you must look at is that
Tells us that 53% of students, another statistic I saw says 57% of students take 6 years to graduate college.
I think it is fair to say the number would be even higher if it was free, and you could take your time.
Here you can see that the average cost of tuition increases by 8% per year.

The number 111,864 is due a 4 year plan with a steady cost of tuition.
The average tuition is roughly $7,700
So the average cost of living is ~$20,000 then $7,700 for tuition.

So if we count the addition of 8% tuition each year, not to mention this statistic is already a few years old so the number is already higher. This was done using a calculator and obviously I cannot read the future it is simply a prediction.
Year 1 $7,700
Year 2 $8,316
Year 3 $8,981.28
Year 4 $9699.78
~Year 5 $10475.76
~Year 6 $11313.83

Now assuming that 55% of students take 6 years you are looking at
20,000 a year + The cost of tuition for 6 years, this is also not including inflation and the increase in the Consumer Price Index, so the numbers would be even higher.

You get ~ 20,000 * 6 + the cost of tuition = $176,487 for a 6 year program
~ 20,000 * 4 + the cost of tuition = $114,697 for a 4 year program

Under the realization there is a lot more to it, I believe that as much as I may have overestimated or valued the prices, it is also possible that they are undervalued, and without calculating inflation or the CPI, I believe it is a fair estimate to base a initial argument off of.

The next topic is the efficiency of public funding
This article goes to say that billions of dollars of public funding are spent each year on students who drop out. This is billions of wasted dollars on someone who never graduated, took the money and ran, if you would. If all of college was paid for this number would increase more and more.

The reason that colleges cost so much is because there is no public funding, the burden of cost is put on the student because it cant be supported by the state.

66% of students receive an average of $9,100 in financial aid.
52% of students receive grants averaging $4,900.
This is in 2007-2008

So already we can see that the cost of college is rising due to a lack of public funding.
Public funding already pays $9,100 a student for 66% of students, with much more in grants to 52% of students.
There is no more money to give out.

If college was free there would be an immediate influx of students, so many you would most likely need to increase the number of colleges, which now costs billions in new colleges, and billions in all the new free-ride students.

From the US Census Bureau, the median salary of an individual who has only a high school diploma is $27,967; The median salary of an individual who has a bachelor's degree is $47,345

The tax bracket in 2012 puts $27,967 in the 15 range, and $47,345 in the 25% range.
The high-school diploma yields 4195.05 in income taxes.
The college diploma yields 11836.25 in income taxes.

That is $7641.20 more from a college graduate than a high-school graduate.
Assuming a average cost (4-6 years) of college, you are looking at ~$150,000 per student.
It will take 20 years in taxes for the student to pay back his debt to society.

I am out of space and will follow up ASAP.
Debate Round No. 1


You have broken the rules of the debate, and that counts as a forfeit usually. I'll let it go if you agree to take the burden of proof in this debate, as you were the one that started arguing first.

Onto my argument:

53% percent of students take 6 years to graduate college:
No, no they don't. 53% percent of students graduate within 6 years. That does not mean those people would waste public funds however. My father took 12 years to finish his Bachelor's and another 5 to finish his Master's because he had to keep quitting his studies to find work to pay for them. In my father's case, at least, it would have significantly reduced his time in college if he had his studies paid for by the government. Even people that drop out might be motivated to do so because they have no money.

...It will take 20 years in taxes for the student to pay back his debt to society...:
That is true. Let's look at the whole picture now.

The high school graduate will pay taxes for about 37 years: 37*4195.05 = 155,216.85.
The college graduate will pay taxes for about 33 years: 33*11,836.25 = 390,596 - 150,000 = 240,596.25.

Your own argument works against you, unfortunately. This doesn't even take into account how many handouts from the government will be evaporated once everyone can fill the high tech jobs not enough people are trained for:

I suppose that there will be people that drop out of college and waste the taxpayer's money, but a lot of things that are less important waste taxpayer's money. Subsidies to large companies and sports teams for example. But that's a different story.

Conclusion: This might actually raise tax revenues for this country. And even if there is a slight loss because some people freeload, the investment in making sure every American has access to the education they need to succeed is far worth it. The government pays for 13 years of schooling for a child, why not add another four?


mobikenobi forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 2


Extend all arguments.


mobikenobi forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 3


Extend all arguments.


mobikenobi forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 4
4 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 4 records.
Posted by M4sterDeb8er 5 years ago
I actually made this debate because I wanted to argue effectively for this viewpoint. I don't think that guy is handling his debate well and I think I could do much better.
Posted by Ron-Paul 5 years ago
Read the home page of this website, and rethink this debate please.
Posted by M4sterDeb8er 5 years ago
FULLY funded.
Posted by adontimasu 5 years ago
Aren't public colleges, by their very definition, funded by the government? :|
No votes have been placed for this debate.