Rich nations should not aid poor nations
Debate Rounds (2)
Con's argument is that aiding a poor country will mean that the poor country will not have to work as hard to profuce goods. I have two ways to respond to that:
1. Aid is not always in producing manufactured items.
2. If a country does not have to work as hard to produce manufactured goods, it can be a positive thing, as it can help develop the country and bring it closer to riches.
1. The act of aid is an act of kindness, and the rich country's reputation will become better.
2. The poor country may feel indebted to the rich country, thus it will feel in the future that it should repay the rich country, will will help the rich country.
I would like to thank Con for starting this debate. Back to Con.
Ibraham_Moizus_18 forfeited this round.
Con's argument: If the poor country does not needs less work to produce goods, then the government of the country may lose its independence, and will not be able to function on its own.
My arguments from before:
1 and 2. Almost all forms of aid could lead to the poor country's loss of independence.
1. If our reputation adds that we are nice, it can send a message to foreign enemies that we could be an easy target.
2. When it comes to being indebted, that is a horrible position for any poor country. If the poor country would be incapable of paying the rich country back, we may be brought back to the time in which we had colonies, whereas the rich country is the mother country and the poor country is the colony. All of this is relevant to independence. Remember what New France was like under French control? It wasn't that good.
I'm sorry for the potential confusion I have caused, but I have refuted my opponent's and my own arguments that support aid (I was playing the devil's advocate in this round). Vote Pro.
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.