Should Test Scores Be 100% of your grade w/ no credit for homework?
Debate Rounds (3)
I will be taking the Pro stance on this debate because I feel that removing the point values from homework is a promising way to innovate the education system.
1. The average grade would decrease, causing the truly exemplary students to more clearly stand out on resumés and applications.
2. Students would be more inclined to actually learn the subject and complete the homework themselves, instead of copying answers on the homework and proceeding to bomb the tests.
3. The quality of teachers would improve, because if a student is curious about a topic, and the teacher's knowledge proves insufficient, the student has the ability to change their schedule. If enough students do this, it would become clear which teachers are truly qualified. The others would be laid off by the school due to the lack of students that would take classes taught by them.
4. Tests are a better way of measuring which students are actually putting forth effort and trying to learn the subject. With homework as it is, students could easily pass a class just by copying answers from friends or other tactics that require no actual effort.
5. The students that still complete homework learn that preparation is the key to success. If homework doesn't have a point value tied to it, its true purpose becomes apparent. Preparation.
1. People who 'freeze up' during tests:
a. Quick decisions are inevitable in life, and people who 'freeze up' in high-stress situations probably won't succeed. Tests would be beneficial to these people, because it helps to prepare them for stress later in life.
a. If points are currently the driving force behind homework completion, then students will soon realize that points still can be earned, but they just have to prepare if they want to receive them.
b. However, even now there are people don't care about the points. They don't complete the homework, and they still won't in this new system. There will be no change in the people who complete and don't complete homework.
It is true that the people who currently complete homework in a legitimate manner would face a small amount of detriment, but the new structure is definitely worth it. They would temporarily drop a few percentage points from their grade, but they would soon realize that they can still get good grades, it just take the independent will to study for them.
With the current system, your teachers can give you ungodly amounts of homework points to buffer your grade in case of a bad test. With the new method, they will lose that ability. The teachers will be able to teach and prepare the students, but they cannot automatically pass them. The new system puts the grade solely in the hands of the students.
You still get paid for homework, just in an indirect way. The students who complete homework and prepare get paid in better test scores. Better test scores = higher points. However, in the current system people don't always have to work. They can still get paid for cheating. That's not a good life lesson. The new system promotes innovation. If the teacher's homework isn't helpful, you can learn it with self-made alternative methods tailored to your specific needs. The new system provides many roads to success, but none of them are reliant on cheating.
If I'm going to do my homework in MY time OUTSIDE of the already 8 HOURS of school then i want the points for it ESPECIALLY if i do it correctly and get it turned in on time unlike the little slackers.
It may not be fair to the students who consistently turn their homework in on time, but it is fair to the students who do so fairly. They will probably notice no change, their overall GPA will remain largely static. However, the system does make it easier to identify the real slackers and cheaters.
The work you do in the time outside of those eight hours is completely optional in both systems. You don't have to do it. You could just fail all the tests. But, if homework is worth points, failing tests isn't nearly as bad as if the homework point buffer is taken away.
The new system will be less forgiving, but will produce students who are more knowledgeable about their subjects and prepared for the real world.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by Walrus101 2 years ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||0||3|
Reasons for voting decision: I feel like Con made this a debate about his/her personal life. Debates are usually hypothetical, and don't have personal experiences to sway you one way. So arguments go to pro for detaching himself.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.