Should homeschooling be allowed in every state?
Debate Rounds (5)
I accept this debate. Good luck to you as well.
Case 1: the benefits of home schooling
In this link, it lists all the benefits of home schooling as well as her sorry home schooling. I quote from the article,
"Why does home schooling get rave reviews?
Individualized, directed learning and flexible pacing
Home schooling brings families closer together
Learning can take place anywhere, anytime
Freedom to explore individual interests and tailored areas of study
Shared learning experiences among siblings on educational field trips and learning adventures
The opportunity to nurture and provide individual attention to your child
Ability to impart family values throughout the learning process
Intimate involvement, knowledge, and guidance regarding your child""s education"
These are some of the benefits from home schooling! Home schooling also benefits people in college
As shown in this link, homeschoolers graduated 9.2% with higher grades than their peers who went to public school.
If my opponent wishes to try to prove me wrong he may do so next round.
Now, I can't prove wrong the benefits that you have stated, but I can show the negative effects homeschooling can have on someone.
My opponent argued that homeschooling can be done anywhere and can bring families closer together.
While this is true, the homeschooled students are not exposed to the social settings that public schools provide. I have a friend that was homeschooled for majority of her life, and you could tell that she lacked in social skills.  shows that not only do homeschoolers lack social skills that public schoolers maintain, but the lack of separation of parent/child create a dependency on the parent from the child. With no separation, the child will become more dependent on the parents, just like with my friend. Now, I am not saying this is always the case, but it is very common.
My opponent also argued that "homeschoolers graduated 9.2% with higher grades."
Now, this quote grammatically does not make sense to me. I actually have no idea what they mean by this quote, so to refute this, all I can say is that, there are less homeschooled people in college than there are public schooled people.  shows that approximately 1.77million people are homeschooled, whereas in 2011, there were 49.5million people that were public schooled . Now, to say that a 100% of homeschoolers go to college and only 10% of public schoolers do (hypothetically), there is still an unfair ratio, allowing more variance and faults in the 4.95million homeschoolers and the 1.77million homeschoolers. You see, when it coms to percentages, you have to carefully examine how many people are counted in each side. And in this, it is definitely biased in the homeschooling favor because if they have 500k with good scores, that makes a higher percent than if 500k public schoolers had good scores.
You failed to account that there are many home school groups made so homeschoolers can get interaction.
This link shows a group in Florida that allows homeschoolers to have grads, dances, and even high school graduation!
Your next argument was about homeschoolers creating a dependency on their parents. These two links prove otherwise.
These two links do not only presents the benefits from home schooling, but also say that homeschoolers are normally the most ready for college compared to children who went to public school. Wouldn't it be the opposite if homeschoolers had a dependency on their parents?
My opponent did not even understand my statement, so therefore I do not think he should have made a rebuttal. Here is what I meant. If you would take a home schooled child, and compared their test scores to a child who went to public school, on average, the home schooled child's test scores would be 9.2% higher than the public school child. This states that the average homeschooler has better test scores than the average public schooled child.
I have negated my opponent's previous arguments from last round. If the opponent wishes to prove me wrong, he can do so this round.
Here are the sources:
There was a colon that interefered and broke the link, sorry.
My opponent argued that homeschoolers are not dependent on their parent/s and get to have social interactions with other homeschoolers.
I cannot deny that the homeschoolers get to have interaction with other people, but when we talk about social interaction, we are talking more on a larger scale. When someone attends public school, they may see new faces everyday, or they may be exposed to the same people in a lot of their classes. These interactions are every day, weekends and holidays excluded. Whereas, a homeschooler may have a fewe field trips a month or even a week, but majority of the time they stay in their home surroundings with their family. When you say they aren't dependent on their parents, please explain why not rather than making everyone read an article. They are around their parents not only after school but during school, creating a stronger bond and dependency on the parent than you would find with public schoolers. Also, there was a statistic on the site about graduation rates, so please read my next rebuttal.
My opponent stated that I should not have refuted their argument and clarifies the argument they made earlier.
Even though I did not understand your argument, I refuted it, so to clarify it did not refute my argument. My argument was based on the populations on both homeschoolers and public schoolers. This is crucial when it comes to percentages and statistics. So, let me make it easier for you. Say you have 20 apples and 30 oranges. Now say 10 of each went bad. That would mean that HALF of the apples are still good and ONE THIRD of the oranges are still good. You see, I brought up population because there are more than TEN TIMES the amount of public schoolers than homeschoolers. This leads to more variance and skew in the publicschooling data, so the homeschooling data would have to get less people score higher to have a higher average than that of the publicschoolers.
It says that socialization is actually common in homeschoolers. If you liked that video, there is a part 2
My opponent clearly did not get my previous statement. Lets just say you pick 20 random kids who go to public school and 20 random kids who are home schooled, and compare their grades. The home schooled group on average would have test scores 9.2% higher than the kids that are public schooled.
I have negated the con's previous statements. If he wishes to prove me wrong, he may do so this round.
JacobAnderson forfeited this round.
JacobAnderson forfeited this round.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by dtaylor971 3 years ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||4||0|
Reasons for voting decision: Due to forfeiture, Anderson loses arguments and conduct. Also, pro had better arguments. My favorite thing that he did was make benefits that were literally not refutable, as said by con.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.