All Big Issues
The Instigator
Pro (for)
Losing
21 Points
The Contender
Con (against)
Winning
46 Points

# Stable nations are a greater threat to the U.S that stable nations

Do you like this debate?NoYes+0

Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 12 votes the winner is...
mongeese
 Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point Started: 10/23/2009 Category: News Updated: 7 years ago Status: Post Voting Period Viewed: 4,926 times Debate No: 9808
Debate Rounds (3)

 Pro Failed nations are a greater threat to the U.S because of the lack of government control, also lack of territory control, and not being able to interact with other countries as a whole. These failed nations are posing several physical threats to the U.S because of all the nuclear power being help by them. Failed nations are also safe havens for terrorism to expand. www.gale.com/harvardinternationalreviewReport this Argument Con My opponent's only paragraph talks about failed nations. However, this debate concerns stable nations and only stable nations. My syllogism will demonstrate why the resolution is negated. 1. Assume that "the threat of stable nations" = A. 2. A = A [1] 3. The comparison "greater" is an inequality. [2] 4. A can be in an inequality with A iff A =/= A. (Definition of "inequality") 5. A cannot be in an inequality with A. (The conclusion of 4 is shown to be false by 2, so the premise of 4 is false.) 6. The threat of stable nations cannot be in an inequality with the threat of stable nations. (Substituting A with "the threat of stable nations," as allowed by 1) 7. The statement "Stable nations are a greater threat to the U.S that stable nations" is an inequality. [2] 8. The statement "Stable nations are a greater threat to the U.S that stable nations" is false. (6,7) 1. http://en.wikipedia.org... 2. http://en.wikipedia.org...Report this Argument Pro This resolution talks about both failed and stable. Most stable nations don't pose a threat because they are allies to use so there for they do not pose a greater threat. Failed nations do pose a greater threat to prove my point I will list some reason *failed nations cause other nations to fail * they hold high nuclear power for example Pakistan * These failed nations create conflict for the U.S because of our unfavorable so there for these failed nations are a over all problem http://en.wikipedia.org...Report this Argument Con "This resolution talks about both failed and stable." Wrong. Look at the top of this page, at the words between my opponent's picture and mine, above "Add to My Favorites," "Report this Debate," and "Share with My Friends." There, you will see the resolution. I have copied and pasted it below: "Stable nations are a greater threat to the U.S that stable nations" Failed nations are completely irrelevant. They are not in the resolution. We are comparing stable nations to stable nations. "Most stable nations don't pose a threat because they are allies to use so there for they do not pose a greater threat." Well, it doesn't matter, because A = A regardless. "Failed nations do pose a greater threat..." Despite my opponent's reasons why failed nations may be a greater threat than stable nations, we are only comparing stable nations to stable nations. Therefore, my opponent's contentions are to be ignored, and my syllogism is to be extended. Good luck.Report this Argument Pro HAHA wow you are so right, man I sure do feel stupid now. you win I need more practice thanks I'm going to need itReport this Argument Con My opponent has been enlightened. Good luck in future debates.Report this Argument
9 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 9 records.
Posted by rougeagent21 7 years ago
LAME. mongeese, you knew what she was talking about ;)
Posted by mongeese 7 years ago
draxxt, you obviously aren't aware of my DDO Win/Loss record history.
Posted by asiandebater 7 years ago
the word key should be guy
Posted by asiandebater 7 years ago
haha some key sent me a message saying that I only recieved votes because of my looks
Posted by draxxt 7 years ago
It happens. Vote bombing is common nowadays... and has been for a while.
Posted by MTGandP 7 years ago
Why does Pro have 13 votes?
Posted by asiandebater 7 years ago
Thats right i will next time be very sure to pay attention to my resolution
Posted by mongeese 7 years ago
PRO will probably never again make this mistake. One debate is all it takes, really, to fix mistakes.

*Looks back at first copyright debate*
Posted by JBlake 7 years ago
Poor conduct by Con, but he is correct.
12 votes have been placed for this debate. Showing 1 through 10 records.