The Instigator
Yavneh
Pro (for)
Tied
0 Points
The Contender
iTruthSeeker
Con (against)
Tied
0 Points

Team Debate: Judaism (Pro) vs. Christianity (Con)

Do you like this debate?NoYes+1
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point
Started: 2/23/2016 Category: Religion
Updated: 2 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 4,380 times Debate No: 86903
Debate Rounds (5)
Comments (110)
Votes (0)

 

Yavneh

Pro

Bs"D

Teams:
Pro: Yavneh, Rami, and anyone else who wishes to accept.
Con: Whoever accepts, plus 1-4 others who they choose.

The debate is defined as trying to prove that either Judaism (defined as Orthodox) or Christianity (whichever sect Con wants, or a group of sects) is more valid than the other. Teams will collaborate on a Google doc to form arguments, rebuttals, etc., and the team member who accepted will post the shared link.

Round 1 is acceptance and list of team members; afterwards, each team argues at their own pace (though no new arguments are allowed in the final round).

Hoping for a good debate.
iTruthSeeker

Con

Accepting for Con (Christianity)

Team:
1).ITruthSeeker
2).Nivek
3).Nawl
4).Jerry943

I look forward to this debate.. Let the games begin!
Debate Round No. 1
Yavneh

Pro

Bs"D
With due credit given to my four teammates, here is the link (It was too many characters to copy and paste):
https://docs.google.com...
Thank you for reading!
iTruthSeeker

Con

Here is the well awaited link:
https://docs.google.com...

I thank my teammates for their participation.

Debate Round No. 2
Yavneh

Pro

Thank you to Con for your arguments.
Thank you to my teammates (who did basically all of the work ;).
Thank you to Rami for the vote of no confidence (see Comments).
Here is our round 3 link:
https://docs.google.com...
Enjoy!
iTruthSeeker

Con

Here is our rebuttal:
https://docs.google.com...

Nawl has decided to quit the team by not responding to our messages.. We could not object to everything we planned on due to this inconvience.. We will respond to your further objections in the first rebuttal next round

Thanks to my teamates for their effort and support.
Debate Round No. 3
Yavneh

Pro

Yavneh forfeited this round.
iTruthSeeker

Con

Here is our Round 4 rebuttal:
https://docs.google.com...

Pro's Instigator (Yavneh) was not availible to post their argument due to certain reasons.. We will be posting their Round 4 rebuttal as well at this link:
https://docs.google.com...

We trust that team Pro did not insert any more arguments/rebuttals after the time limit was reached..

Thanks to my team for participating and giving well thought out arguments. Cheers to the final round!


Debate Round No. 4
Yavneh

Pro

Thank you to Con for a good debate, and for posting our argument when I ran into the Sabbath.
Sorry to the readers for our forfeit last time.
Finally, a huge thank you to my teammates, who made this debate happen: Rami, Harrytruman, Talmid, and (last but by no means least) CapAhab. You were amazing to work with.

Here is our argument: https://docs.google.com...

Please do not edit, by the way, because my teammate has not yet put it on 'view'. All edits will be easily reversible.

Thank you to everyone for a great debate, and we hope we earned your vote!
iTruthSeeker

Con

Alright here is our final argument:
https://docs.google.com...

Thanks to everyone for their participation in this debate! This is by far, the most extensive debate I have participated in on this site and am well pleased to have shared it with you all!

God bless!
Debate Round No. 5
110 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 10 records.
Posted by mosc 1 month ago
mosc
Where from the Torah did the prophet Moshe teach the concept of Moshiach? Aaron.

What does holy mean? Something dedicated unto HaShem which nothing else can replace.

Moshe in his humility anointed Aaron and the house of Aaron as the Moshiach, Head of House of the Jewish people for ever. Check out the first word of the Torah in Hebrew, within its 6 letters contains the words "head of House"/Rosh Biet!

Within the Torah, did anyone challenge the House of Aaron as the eternal anointed Moshiach? Korach.

Within the literature of the NaCH did anyone challenge the House of Aaron as the eternal anointed Moshiach? Shlomo and Yerov'am, the 2nd king of Yechuda and Israel and the first king of Israel respectively - both worshiped avoda zarah.

If the house of Aaron stands as the eternal Moshiach, then what role does the anointed house of David play? The house of David stands anointed as the continuation of Moshe the law giver. Shaul, HaShem rejected as being king b/c he did not obey the commandments of the prophet Shmuel. G'lut came upon both kingdoms of Yechuda and Israel b/c both kingdoms, according to the Books of the NaCH, failed like as did king Shaul, the Torah commandments of Moshe the king.
Posted by mosc 1 month ago
mosc
The noise testament which jabbers about jesus son of Zeus mythology never once bring the Name of HaShem in any of its Books! This violates the 1st and 2nd commandments of Sinai. Goyim by definition never accept the Torah revelation at Sinai. The other 8 commandments the law giver Moshe the prophet commanded Israel in the Name of HaShem. Moshe the prophet commanded in all 611 commandments.

The church does not recognize the 611 commandments which the prophet commands the people who accept the Torah revelation of Sinai to keep and to do. Therefore the Noise Testament violates all the Torah commandments, beginning with honesty.
Posted by iTruthSeeker 2 years ago
iTruthSeeker
Im up!
Posted by CapAhab 2 years ago
CapAhab
I'm up for a team continuation debate... Who's up?
Posted by iTruthSeeker 2 years ago
iTruthSeeker
Who said I was gonna take you on alone? I wouldn't mind doing a 1v1 if your up for it
Posted by Rami 2 years ago
Rami
Well, You might be the only person on this sight that reads the debate settings before accepting. We had two other cases where hotshots try to take us all at once.
Posted by iTruthSeeker 2 years ago
iTruthSeeker
Anybody up for a round 2? I got time :)
Posted by Jerry947 2 years ago
Jerry947
Thanks to my team mates and thanks to the opponents. That was a really neat debate in which I hope everyone learned something.
Posted by Nivek 2 years ago
Nivek
The doc is fine. It's taxing enough to have you do all those. Anyway, thanks to my team for working diligently and thanks to truth for formulating everything from R1 to R5. In addition, the reminders he made were also useful and thank you Jerry for carrying the arguments. My only contribution is about 4 pages, lol. Alas, I hope you have a better team for part 2. Good luck.
Posted by iTruthSeeker 2 years ago
iTruthSeeker
I think the non-team voting is a given, but I will agree to it.

I would be up for a round 2 sometime in the future... I need some time to rest and re-calibrate from our last round XD
No votes have been placed for this debate.