Was Serbia responsible for the First World War?
Debate Rounds (4)
Germany confronted Serbia over the assassination because they were close allies with Austria-Hungary and felt the need to protect them, even though it certainly wasn't needed.
Serbia was allied with Russia and Austria-Hungary was allied with Germany. So when Franz Ferdinand was assassinated, Austria-Hungary made ultimatums to Serbia (which was an incredibly dumb decision), and Germany agreed with those ultimatums. Serbia did not agree with the ultimatums, so they did not accept them. Austria-Hungary got violent with Serbia (and so did Germany), and Russia came to defend them.
So, if anything, WW1 was caused because Austria-Hungary and Germany got too butthurt.
Serbia was in no way responsible for the war.
they rebelled against the Austria-Hungarian Empire, causing them to declare war on Serbia Serbia caused WWI, because of a young boy called Gavrilo Princip who killed Archduke Franz Ferdinand. Gavrilo Princip was from the Black Hand gang, a Serbian Nationalist group. Their aim was to free Serbia from Austria-Hungary, which wanted to take over the Balkan states which was once part of Turkish Empire. So Austria-Hungary had also caused the war indirectly.
One more thing, Serbia was also one of the Balkan states.
The US was responsible for providing assistance to the group that killed Osama Bin Laden. I know Laden and Ferdinand are on completely different levels, but does that count as terrorism? Does a person killing someone from a different country count as terrorism? Take President Garfield's assassination for example. Guiteau, his killer (though born in Illinois), was a strong supporter of the French, tried to make offices in France, and had French family. Garfield's murder didn't lead to war with France, now did it?
The above example proves that WW1 was Austria-Hungary's fault, because they got way too upset over the assassination. If Austria-Hungary didn't get so upset, WW1 wouldnt've happened.
Serbia did not rebel against the Austro-Hungarian Empire, it was just a simple assassination by a Serbian man.
If anything, anything at all, to literally the smallest point, WW1 was caused by a bad driver. Ferdinand would've lived if it weren't for his driver taking the wrong turn.
GUYS, DRIVE SAFE.
IF YOU DON'T, YOU COULD CAUSE A WORLD WAR.
pariashi forfeited this round.
PatriotPerson forfeited this round.
Serbia should formally and publicly condemn the "dangerous propaganda" against Austria-Hungary, the ultimate aim of which is to "detach from the Monarchy territories belonging to it". Moreover, Serbia should "suppress by every means this criminal and terrorist propaganda".
Moreover, the Serbian government should
1.Suppress all publications which "incite hatred and contempt of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy" and are "directed against its territorial integrity".
2.Dissolve the Serbian nationalist organisation "Narodna Odbrana" ("The People's Defense") and all other such societies in Serbia.
3.Eliminate without delay from schoolbooks and public documents all "propaganda against Austria-Hungary".
4.Remove from the Serbian military and civil administration all officers and functionaries whose names the Austro-Hungarian Government will provide.
5.Accept in Serbia "representatives of the Austro-Hungarian Government" for the "suppression of subversive movements".
6.Bring to trial all accessories to the Archduke's assassination and allow "Austro-Hungarian delegates" (law enforcement officers) to take part in the investigations.
7.Arrest Major Voja Tankosi? and civil servant Milan Ciganovi? who were named as participants in the assassination plot.
8.Cease the cooperation of the Serbian authorities in the "traffic in arms and explosives across the frontier"; dismiss and punish the officials of the at Shabatz Loznica frontier service, "guilty of having assisted the perpetrators of the Sarajevo crime".
9.Provide "explanations" to the Austro-Hungarian Government regarding "Serbian officials" who have expressed themselves in interviews "in terms of hostility to the Austro-Hungarian Government".
10.Notify the Austro-Hungarian Government "without delay" of the execution of the measures comprised in the ultimatum.
It depends on what you're looking at as far as who did what.
If you were looking at the start of the war it was all done by a terrorist organization called the Black Hand. But as far as who really started it all I would say Gavrilo Princip, who shot the Archduke and his wife. Soon afterwards in a few weeks, Europe spiraled into war. In my honest opinion....I think it was all one man, not the country of Serbia itself.
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.