imagination is false, and belief is imaginary
Debate Rounds (5)
belief=be lie, as i dont know is true
i dont know=i have to imagine it=i can at best imagine it=maybe
my personal physical experience of now is everything, and anywhere beyond that is the reflection of nothing
Ok so your resolution has 2 points that you must prove are correct:
1)imagination is always false
2)belief is imaginary
So I will mainly attack the first because this is an extremely strong and incorrect claim.
1 - -
Imagination is not always false, we imagine ourselves in others positions, this doesn't make them false, it doesn't make the thought false. We imagine tomorrow, but tomorrow isn't false. You can even imagine a location and the location isnt false. This is where your logic is flawed, the act or concept of imagination is based off of prior experiences, we know that trees are made of wood because we have learned or experienced this. Thus nothing in your immagination is false, it is simply based off of things you have experienced. Children imagine monsters, you may think this is false, however the components that form these monsters are inherited from real world things, thus they are not false but misplaced.
2 - -
Belief is Imaginary
To imagine is to compose a thought within yourself, to believe is to have faith in someone elses statement. These are different and thus this is an incorrect statement.
you cannot break belief up in English, you must go back to its origin.
gelyfan or belief does not contain liogan, or lie. Thus the origin of belief does not contain lie, meaning its definition-ally different.
i dont know - I you have absolutely no knowledge of it then you wouldnt be able to imagine it, nor would you realise you dont know it.
my personal physical experience of now is everything, and anywhere beyond that is the reflection of nothing:
Quite the quote but this means that no history, or science you have physically experienced is true.
thoughts are not real, lies exist thou
i cant grab a tree i imagine
its simply true that imagination is false.. it like saying reality is false.. its you having to prove your case that imagination is false
if you imagine a mountain does your head explode?
memory is what i have experienced, truth, and imagination is false, like santa
belief is emotional attachment to information, or to put it more simply, guessing while not knowing it is true
i cant be a lie without having a belief
in an endless amount of possibilities , i still dont know the looks of one unseen
physical experience is true, you cant phyically experience your imagination
I can imagine water, does water exist? yes, thus imagination can be true.
no imagining a mountain will not make my head explode, however mountains are real thus your imagining something true.
a lie doesnt mean it is believed, if I lie and tell you im 9ft tall, Ive lied and you dont believe it.
Your imagination is based off physical experience thus they are one in the same.
so imagine something that you can show me real fast then, shouldnt be a problem
physical is the opposite of mental..
are you serius?
I'm imagining this debate. Its real.
you mentally store physical experiences
and yes I am.
lies are complicated by separation and true is simple now as one
anything i imagine is false, you can imagine whatever you like, you can imagine opra is involved in this debate and you cant get her screaming voice out of your head until you stop believing in god
thats right i have memory.. and imagination would be the opposite of that. fantasy is illogical, memory is logical
You cant show that EVERY POSSIBLE THING that someone imagines is false, its literally impossible to do so, im imagining lunch, and i know its real because ive seen it, i imagine its taste and i know it is true. thus I am imagining something true.
also, this : i can imagine whatever i want.. it isnt contingent upon memory or else i would no be able to lie
simply is a lie, you can lie and know something 100%, If i break a lamp, i know its broken, but i can still lie about it, and imagine it still exists.
imagination is based in memory
can reality happen? is your neighbour home right now?
so, stop eating real food........................................... and just imagine eating food for the next week, shouldnt be a problem there
so if you imagine the lamp didnt break, which is the truth?
imagination is the opposite of memory.. illogical and logical, future and past
i cant die in a dream, as i can only die if i am alive
This is fallacious again... ignorato elenchi
This doesn't relate, I can imagine truths, I show that because I can imagine food before i buy and eat it.
If i gave you a list of giberish like this:
and said they were food, and asked you to draw them, you would have no idea, and thus not immagine anything, instead you would take attributes from other food and assign them to my menu. But if i said:
You could imagine everyone and choose what you want.
imagination is based off of memory.
You can imagine youre death and it will occur, but the type of death you imagine is based off of thought.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by 9spaceking 1 year ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||0||3|
Reasons for voting decision: pro merely made assertions but did not support them well. Con showed that you CAN imagine specific things (i.e. people, food like pizza) that are true. Thus con wins.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.