should teachers be paid more?
Debate Rounds (1)
Teachers are very important to society and I believe that their salaries should be raised. In the United States, teachers are paid between $39,580 and $75,279. Despite the salaries of our teachers, our country"s students are lagging behind other countries in test scores. Teachers are unappreciated even thought they have the most important jobs; educating the next generation. Raising teacher"s pay would emphasize how we value education in this country.
American schools have become a hazardous work environment with the epidemic of school shootings. Due to the shootings, teachers are put in harms way every day. I see how some people might say that the school shootings have only happened a few times and that they do drills for those situations, but it is still unsafe. In addition to the possible harm, teachers are continuously exposed to students that are uncooperative and diagnosed with ADHD and other learning disabilities like ADD. Teachers have to change the way they teach for certain students who learn differently. Children"s respect for teachers is lowering, stopping them from listening and making it harder to teach. Some teachers train for these certain kids, but they are still harder to work with.
Teachers should be paid more, because they pay for most of their students" supplies and the supplies in the classroom. All of the classroom essentials tend to add up to least $500. Teachers should not have to pay for supplies with such low pay. Either the school should pay for the supplies or raise their teachers" pay so they can afford the supplies. Schools may pay for some of the supplies, and some students bring their own. But, what is provided usually isn"t enough and the teachers end up covering the shortfalls.
Finally, teachers should be paid more because education is essential for success in society. As Nicholas Kristof argued in his New York Times op-ed; we need to pay the teachers more to attract more eligible employees. For example, if teachers are paid less, people who are qualified won"t apply for the job because they won"t get enough income for their families. When there are not enough qualified teachers, the schools employ people who are not as experienced to teach, therefore making our teachers not as respectable. In Finland, the teachers are paid less than in America, but the students are more successful and score higher than our students. Why? Teachers in Finland are respected. The teaching profession is hard to get there, making the people who get to go to school for teaching an honor. All of Finland"s teachers are qualified, and most people there want to be a teacher. One of the most important aspects to the people in Finland is Education. The Finnish think that education is their way out of poverty. The schools there are a very relaxed environment. In Finland teachers are respected as much as doctors and their pay should reflect that.
In conclusion, teachers are an essential part of our society; teaching all of the next generation how to do well in society. Teachers have very challenging jobs, with children that are difficult to work with. People in different places educate their children differently. All teachers should be respected, no matter where and how they teach. Raising the salaries of teachers is America is just one way we can show that they are valued for what they contribute to the future of our students.
Raising pay alone won't boost teacher quality: In a recent study, teachers were paid twice, and education quality diminished.
Teacher Benefits: They usuasally retire with health care and a 3 month vacation and recieve a 55,000 salary which is more than the average person.
Taxes: Raising teacher pay increases taxes and debt.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by RedMoonlight 1 year ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||3||2|
Reasons for voting decision: Interesting and under - discussed topic, so I would have liked to see a longer and more detailed debate. Both sides made great arguments, however. I'm voting the way I am primarily because Pro appeared to fulfill his BoP that there are compelling reasons why teachers should be paid more. Con, while bringing up several good points, did not refute Pro's reasons. However, Con did support their argument with sources, which Pro failed to do.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.