the roman catholic church has never contradicted itself
Debate Rounds (3)
you would think if the catholic church were not true, that it would have contradicted itself at some point in two thousand years.
the only things that count are statements that are authoritative, things that could be considerted "infallible". the pope, intentionally, teaches, the church, on faith and morals. that is the criteria. it includes many councils and other statements by popes.
Belief and enforcement of the Geocentric Model
"However, the transition between these two theories met much resistance, not only from the Catholic Church and its reluctance to accept a theory not placing God's creation at the center of the universe, but also from those who saw geocentrism as a fact that could not be subverted by a new, weakly justified theory."
Pope John Paul II regretted the treatment which Galileo received
Abuse of the Sale of Indulgences
Martin Luther's commentary on the subject. 95 Thesis.
The Pope drops Catholic ban on condoms in historic shift
Pope says sorry for sins of church
"John Paul II yesterday attempted to purify the soul of the Roman Catholic church by making a sweeping apology for 2,000 years of violence, persecution and blunders."..."Yesterday's apology was by far the most sweeping and an unprecedented act for the leader of a major religion. One of the highlights of this year's jubilee, or holy year, it was the result of four years' research by a panel of 28 theologians and scholars. ... Disquiet that the apology was a beautiful gesture but a theological mistake bubbled to the surface last week."
regretting treatment of galileo only shows that he was sorry for the acts of former catholics. same arguments go for your point about apologizing for past sins. impeccability does not mean infallibility. they aren't pervect, jsut like the apostles weren't perfect. peter even denied jesus three times, etc. yet we stil read teh bible etc. do as said, not as done. official teaching again is the criteria.
indulgences are said to be part of the churches ability to forgive sins, "Jesus breatehd on them and gave them the holy spirit, saying whose sins ye forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins ye retain are retained". they say this is forgiving the temperal punishment due to sin. you can disagree with this all you want, but it's not a contradiction. sale might be a bad act, but it's due to the sinful nature of men, not a teaching of the church.
the pope didn' t reverse stance on condom use. even in that article, it merely says he's recognizing that it's a lesser evil than spreading disease, liek from a male prostitute. but that doesn't mean it's okay, and he says tehre that it's still immoral. nothign changed. in fact the articles at the bottom of that one address the "confusion" with the popes words that were created, spread about by that article and folks like you. taken all out of context.
I now shift direction: the Catholic church believes in the bible, and the bible has contradictions.
Most famous of which is salvation through faith alone vs salvation through faith and works. 
 Ephesians 2:8-9
 James 2:14-26
the bible is too full of interpretation to say the the RCChurch has contradicted itself.
faith is the bottomline of what saves... but all agree works must be necessary. protestants say works result from salvation, catholics say it's part of salvation. the bible verses don't spell out which is correct. it's most ly just academic "what ifs" anyway.
faith alone doesn't save, said James in that chapter.... works being necessary. yet we wee in romans that Abraham was saved by faioth. it's just a amtter of how you reconcile all thse verses. too mucn interpretation. it's not a contradiction issue.
The bible needs an interpreter, as my opponent pointed out. It cannot all be true. It is not all true.
James in James 2, and Paul in Ephesians 2, are contradictory.
This is born out in the conversation between Paul and Peter in the book of Acts.
If James and Paul had a conversation about the topic, they would NOT be in agreement, they would be yelling.
Please read the three passages in question. In all seriousness, please recognize the obvious contradictions, take into account the context, and vote Con.
 Acts 15
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.