Debate Rounds (4)
(2) It is not simply that the person is coerced into saying or doing what they don"t want to do. Breaking a person"s will should be more clearly explained.
(3) This premise is too vague; there needs to be a definition of both morals and ethics.
(4) Contrarily, ethics asks us to pay attention to something beyond ourselves.
(5) There could be a possible situation where the lives of innocents can be saved, but maximalist torture is used instead of minimalist torture.
(6) Since maximalist torture damages the victim"s autonomy and self-identity irretrievably, it is not morally justifiable.
(7) Therefore all kinds of torture are not minimally morally justifiable
controversial- the definition in premise 4 comes from the basics of ethics packet.
(2) The purpose of torture is to cause someone to cease to act in accordance with his or her own will and act in accordance to the will of the torturer.
(3) What is moral is ethical.
(4) Ethics is acting in accordance with what is right and wrong.
(5) What is meant by saying that something is minimally, morally acceptable, is that there are some exceptions in which torture is permissible, whereas other cases it is impermissible
(6) Cases where the lives of innocents can be saved such as bomb threats and car jacks with children in the car are cases where necessary minimalist torture is morally justifiable.
(7) minimal torture only affects the person being tortured for a short period of time where as in a maximal torture they are tortured for a long period of time, therefore minimal torture is permissible and maximal torture is not.
(8) Necessary minimalist torture is morally justifiable.
(9) Minimalist torture is torture in where the tortured can still physically and psychological functions after the torture occurs.
(10)Torture is morally justifiable if presented with imminent threat to the life or lives of other.
(11)Therefore torture is minimally morally justifiable
No votes have been placed for this debate.
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.