will Indian defense be able to stand out if China breaks out a war?
Debate Rounds (3)
I believe that if China breaks out war against India, the Indian defence would not be able to stand out.
Let me present to you some numbers and facts associated with them in order to clarify my view.
Number of regular army men
China 16 lakh + Reserve forces 8 lakh + PAP 660000 = 3060000 total
India 1325000 + Reserve forces 18 lakh + territorial army = 37 lakh plus total.
China Tanks 7500, Artillery guns 20000, Helicopters 400, armoured vehicles 7500 +
India Tanks 5000, Artillery guns 19800, Helicopters 500, armoured vehicles number not known
Surface to Air Missiles
China 210000 - India 190000
Besides these China has deployed around 1800 ballistic missiles some of which have nuclear warheads. (Range between 280-350 kemps up to 13000 kemps).
On the other hand India has over 1700 missiles belonging to the Prithvi, Agni and Brahmos supersonic Cruise missile category (range between 150 kms upto 5500 kms). Besides these India has also developed a land based missile named Shaurya (range upto 2200 kms) and its submarine based version named Sagarika, both of which are supposed to be in service shortly or might have already been inducted.
The part where India really lags behind China in terms of numbers is the number of aircraft possessed by their airforces and the vessels operated by their respective navies.
China has over 2000 fighter and bomber aircrafts belonging to categories such as Jian, Jianhong, Chengdu, Hong 6, Qiang 5, FC-17, Suk hoi 27 and Suk hoi 30 MKK. (It has to be noted here that over 60% of these aircrafts are second and third generation aircrafts and a large number of those may not even be combat ready. The Suk hoi 30 MKK aircraft which is the premier fighter craft for China is technologically much inferior compared to the Suk hoi 30 MKI version that Indian Air force operates. Suk hoi 30 MKK can actively engage two targets simultaneously.
India has about 700-800 fighter and bomber aircrafts about 300 belong to the Mg 21 category and 100 to the Mg 27 category. The remaining comprises Mg 29 Air superiority fighters, Mirage 2000 H (being upgraded to M), Jaguar bomber crafts and 98 Suk hoi 30 MKI aircrafts. (Indian air force aircrafts apart from the Mg 21 series are third and fourth generation aircrafts with the Suk hoi 30 MKI being a generation 4.5 aircraft that can actively engage up to 20 different targets simultaneously (8 of them offensively and tracking the remaining) and can also act as a leader aircraft to a squadron of fighter planes. All of these aircrafts are supersonic planes with the Suk hoi 30 MKI being far superior to any other aircraft possessed by the Chinese Air force. Besides these, India also operates over 380 UAV's that can perform various roles including missile attacks and bombings.
Don"t you think India would stand out.
Russia came to help during 1971 also. It was the one giving information to India when the Chinese trespassed the border in 1962 and broke out a war. Russia has promised to share most of their weapons and missiles and even if we don't take their help, we are self-sufficient to defend ourselves. The army is in full enthusiasm and also, we have been developing our military forces.
mindsetter forfeited this round.
RiyaChettiyar forfeited this round.
mindsetter forfeited this round.
1 votes has been placed for this debate.
Vote Placed by Ragnar 3 years ago
|Agreed with before the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Agreed with after the debate:||-||-||0 points|
|Who had better conduct:||-||-||1 point|
|Had better spelling and grammar:||-||-||1 point|
|Made more convincing arguments:||-||-||3 points|
|Used the most reliable sources:||-||-||2 points|
|Total points awarded:||0||0|
Reasons for voting decision: Neither side cared enough to finish the debate...
You are not eligible to vote on this debate
This debate has been configured to only allow voters who meet the requirements set by the debaters. This debate either has an Elo score requirement or is to be voted on by a select panel of judges.