Debate.org members
Drug Legalization Debates
Drug Legalization Debates
History and Debate of Drug Legalization
Drug liberalization is a term that refers to the elimination of laws that prohibit drug use. There are several types of drug liberalization, but the most common are drug decriminalization and drug re-legalization. Drug re-legalization is a process that calls for an end to the government-enforced prohibition of certain substances. This ranges from full legalization, which would completely remove all control, to partial legalization, which means that drugs would be available but only under controlled circumstances.
Types of Legalization
Controlled legalization could include mandated labels with dosage instructions as well as restrictions on advertising. Age limitations, restrictions on the amount purchased at one time and requirements on the form supplied could also be imposed. Some proponents of partial liberalization also call for bans on sale to intoxicated individuals and possible licensing requirements. Some drugs are already available under this partially legalized system. Nicotine, alcohol, caffeine and antibiotics are supplied under regulations such as these.
Full legalization would involve absolutely no government regulation. This type of policy is usually proposed by libertarians who believe that the government has no right to dictate what people put into their bodies. Some also oppose drug regulation because they believe that regulation only adds to the problem by adding to the appeal of using certain drugs.
Drug decriminalization is a type of drug liberalization that involves reduced control and penalties for drug use than those that are called for in the current laws. The use of fines rather than prison sentences is supported by this type of policy. Those who are caught using illegal drugs are fined, but do not receive any permanent criminal record. Drug decriminalization has taken place in several jurisdictions for cannabis. California, New York and several other states have decriminalized this drug and now only impose fines on people who are found with less than a certain amount.
Economics often come into play when discussing the legalization of drugs. Those who support drug liberalization argue that criminalization supports an increase in crimes such as theft and homicide. In many developing nations, drug sales can provide a way of escaping poverty. Those who are against drug liberalization argue that drug legalization would increase the prevalence of use and decrease the productivity of the average worker.
Historically, the use of psychoactive drugs has been illegal in the United States except for in certain cases of religious observance or medical practice. The War on Drugs is a modern movement to kick drugs out of America and has gained support over the years. Current opponents of the War on Drugs mainly push for a softening of laws that regulate cannabis, prescription drugs and psychedelics. Hard drugs such as heroin and cocaine are typically left alone.
Drug Legalization Debates
In analyzing the arguments for and against drug liberalization in the United States, many individuals examine the regulations of other nations. In Canada, the cultivation of cannabis is illegal except for certain instances of medical usage. However, there is a huge campaign to make the substance legal nationwide. Brazil has followed a policy of decriminalization over the last several decades. Drug use is punishable only with a fine, while drug traffickers can be punished with prison time.
Humans have been using psychedelic drugs since the beginning of time, but laws to regulate these substances are a rather new concept. Drug liberalization seems to be the new trend, but to what degree will the government relax drug laws before it is too much?
For Drug Legalization
Pro
Comment: Legalization would eliminate the drug cartels overnight, and overall crime rates would plummet. Individuals would have greater freedom. And local rehabilitation centers are much more effective than prison time.
Comment: 500% tax.
Comment: The drug war has cost many lives and corrupts cops and politicians. I have the right to do with my body as I see fit.
Comment: Pro for some drugs, especially the softer ones. Con to harder drugs such as meth and cocaine.
Comment: Victimless crimes are not crimes.
Comment: Our government does not exist to legislate morality and prohibition merely feeds the black market and the myriad vices associated with it.
Comment: Drugs only hurt the user. They infringe on no one else's rights. Smoke weed evryday.
Comment: Only for legalization of some drugs that have very little side effects or causes little harm (although all drugs cause some harm).
Comment: At least weed.
Comment: I'll always debate this. The War on Drugs hasn't worked and has left Mexico a disaster zone.
Against Drug Legalization
Con
Comment: Although I completely agree that drugs only harm the user and that it shouldn't exactly be a "crime", I feel that the full legalization of drugs (I okay with marijuana legalization) will only harm the society more than it would help. This is one of the few times I will put Efficiency > Liberty.
Comment: Marijuana should never be made legal or any other drugs; and, I used to smoke the crap. The crime and addiction rates in countries that have legalized drugs have increased substantially. And, those countries are now rethinking and changing the laws. Alcohol destroys more lives and families and is responsible for more lost days at work and medical expenses than any other reason. Adding Marijuana will only make that worse. And, over 16,000 are murdered annually by drunk drivers, it will only increase if you legalize pot. Too many kids in high school and even grade school are becoming stoners. The Federal Government needs to crack down on all the states that have legalized it, and quickly.
Comment: Day after drugs are made legal: average life expectancy plummets, production falls, and the average college student is always high. Great idea.
Comment: If drugs endanger the public like alcohol through drunk driving I want them severely regulated. I don't think alcoholics should be able to drink at public establishments unless they aren't allowed to leave, forcibly, until testing sober, and that alcohol should not be made available for sale otherwise.
Comment: Support decriminalization of soft drugs, but not legalization.
Comment: Im on board for marijuana legalization, but im against legalizing other hardcore drugs like meth and crack.
Comment: The drugs that are illegal are absolutely useless to civilization.
Comment: the cause of so much harm
Comment: Perhaps legalization of drugs such as marijuana with regulation, but no @ more serious drugs
Comment: Drugs make people stupid. They negatively affect the lives of so many people.

