Debate.org members
European Union Debates
European Union Debates
History and Debate of European Union
The European Union is a group of 27 member politically and economically allied nations. The original union was based on the trade of coal and steel between six nations, but it has increased in size since 1958. The EU has a single market and a set of laws that apply in all states. People are allowed to move freely from state to state, and goods and services are also traded freely. In addition, the EU has its own currency, called the Euro. Over 500 million people live in the EU, which is about 7 percent of the world population. The GDP is about 16.2 billion US dollars. However, there is still some controversy regarding whether this is the best economic arrangement for these European nations. Many believe it benefits some nations and not others, but supporters argue that it enhances all economies and builds stronger cultural ties.
Potential Pros to the European Union Debate
One of the main pros of the EU is that people traveling from nation to nation, which they often do in Europe, only have to carry one form of currency. They do not have to go through the hassle of making exchanges or figuring out exchange rates.
Another benefit to this system is that it allows people to move freely between nations, which makes it easier for people to work internationally. People have more say in where they live and can move to better climates if they desire. Supporters of the EU also argue this arrangement keeps more money in Europe, as it reduces the amount of trade necessary with nations outside of the EU. It also allows for competition with larger nations, such as China and the United States, which is not possible for small nations on their own.
Arguments to the European Union Debate
Those who are against the EU have several reasons for their opinions. Many believe the Euro has contributed to the economic crisis in Europe, since struggling member nations tend to pull down the entire European Union. Those that would not struggle on their own endure more financial hardship as a result. Other opponents of the EU believe it makes it harder to regulate the influx of immigrants and refugees. Some nations may also lose their skilled workers, since they can move to other EU nations so easily.
Another criticism of the EU is that making changes in laws across all involved nations costs money and results in a rise in taxes. In addition, though the EU was designed to prevent war, some believe disagreements over policies could result in violence.
For European Union
Pro
Comment: Britain needs the EU. We can kid ourselves all we like, but by saying "up yours" to France and Germany we're essentially guaranteeing ourselves 50 years of sour relations.
Comment: A European Union which has became more democratised.
Comment: Their people, too.
Comment: Better that Europe be working together than fighting each other and sooner or later dragging in America to sort out the mess
Comment: I support the organization of all the countries and the streamlining of currency and economic practices
Comment: I oppose the current EU - I would go one step further, Europe should be entirely united - what a force for peace, freedom, and equality France and Germany would be together!
Comment: Why not?
Comment: With regulation.
Comment: The fewer nations there are, the fewer the possibilities for war, inequity, et cetera. Europe has been at the core of global political instability for centuries, and United Europe is the last best hope to both bring peace to Europe and begin the experiments necessary to bring about a true world government.
Comment: We should also have an American Union, but not NAFTA. We need to include free movement along with free trade. (Why should goods be free to move but not people?). And a common currency. Extending human rights, environmental protection agreements, and labor laws to all members of the union could help develop standards of living throughout the Western Hemisphere. When the United States declared the Monroe Doctrine we pledged our support for all peoples in this hemisphere. We should even let Cuba in so long as they adopt free and fair elections and human rights protections. They can stay communist if they want, so long as they become a communist democracy.
Against European Union
Con
Comment: The European Union diminishes the power of sovereign nations within it, and causes the political and economic impact of one country to weigh down the others. In my opinion, it was conceived only as a means of competition for European countries to have a shot at the global market with massive competitors like the Soviet Union and the United States.
Comment: Europe's bad, union's bad, hehehe. Also isn't constraining looters like Greece, which is the one thing it might have been good for.
Comment: Stupid morons unite!
Comment: The EU is a failure! It is doing nothing but dragging the global economy down.
Comment: The European Union is a joke at its true central purpose is to protect the interests of the mega corporations and the wealthy Plutocracy. The bottom line for America is foreign trade with the members of the European Unions, which is part of America’s Globalization which is just for America’s Plutocracy, increasing earnings so that trillions more can be paid in dividends to the Plutocracy. When the mega America corporation trade with these foreign countries it rarely results in benefits for the real Americans â€" the 99%, the real workers â€" it mainly helps the plutocracy. All corporation and businesses throughout the world need to be employee owned and profits shared equally by all employees.
Comment: Euro. Nuff said.
Comment: Seems like a major economic catastrophe to me.
Comment: they support big government
Comment: Exhibit A: Europe
Comment: Corruption and bailouts everywhere -- a total failure.

