Wal-Mart Mafia DP6

At 5/28/2012 5:22:26 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 4:41:21 PM, Buddamoose wrote:

At 5/28/2012 3:52:46 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:
Guys, while I think Ober said something stupid, I doubt he is scum unless he was recently recruited.

I had a powerful role that I outed at the beginning of the game in the mason pm. I did not think that there would be a traitor and when everyone else said they had mason pms, I got suspicious. If there were any scum in my pm, I would have been killed early in the game.

Who was in your PM with you to start the game?

Me, Ober and DetectableNinja. Dninja never even posted and was killed during the first NP.

Due to this, I find it highly unlikely that Ober is scum.

If it's only you and Ober left then if you died it would be a no-brainer as to who mafia was, since he knew your complete role. They haven't killed you because it would give him away too easily.

Don't you find it a bit odd that all other pm's have scum but not yours??

At 5/28/2012 9:03:05 PM, medic0506 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 5:22:26 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 4:41:21 PM, Buddamoose wrote:

At 5/28/2012 3:52:46 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:
Guys, while I think Ober said something stupid, I doubt he is scum unless he was recently recruited.

I had a powerful role that I outed at the beginning of the game in the mason pm. I did not think that there would be a traitor and when everyone else said they had mason pms, I got suspicious. If there were any scum in my pm, I would have been killed early in the game.

Who was in your PM with you to start the game?

Me, Ober and DetectableNinja. Dninja never even posted and was killed during the first NP.

Due to this, I find it highly unlikely that Ober is scum.

If it's only you and Ober left then if you died it would be a no-brainer as to who mafia was, since he knew your complete role. They haven't killed you because it would give him away too easily.

Don't you find it a bit odd that all other pm's have scum but not yours??

In addition, if you were killed and flipped town then that would only leave Ober, all alone in the only pm where scum hasn't been found yet. He would be lynched, if nothing else, as a precautionary measure.

At 5/28/2012 5:33:19 PM, OberHerr wrote:
Wow, you guys actually took my comment as a "scum-tell?"

You REALLY think that when I said that, I meant that I'm Mafia, and that I was talking about ending the game for the Town, which if I was Mafia, I have no idea why I would say that out loud, and not just end it.

My growing suspicion of you has nothing to do with that comment. It began when I noticed that your behavior, lurking and inactivity, was very similar to your behavior in Frere Jacques mafia, where you were mafia. Then my suspicion was fueled by my doubt about Blue2's role. If he's pgo then you and Vamp should be dead. I originally thought you could be town, and him be mafia, but that doesn't work if you actually gave him truth serum. That means that if he's mafia then you have to be as well, and lied about recycling the truth serum. Instead you could have recycled something else, and faked the truth serum, giving false confirmation to both you and Blue.

Also, anyone notice that Budda has been sowing this constant doubt among the Town, the WHOLE GAME so far? Now, if he was just some unassuming CULT, that had no intentions of winning ahead of the Town, why would he do this?

Yes we've seen that, but he does have a point about your lack of scumhunting. You've been voting, and providing your results, but have done little else besides that.

At 5/28/2012 9:03:05 PM, medic0506 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 5:22:26 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 4:41:21 PM, Buddamoose wrote:

At 5/28/2012 3:52:46 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:
Guys, while I think Ober said something stupid, I doubt he is scum unless he was recently recruited.

I had a powerful role that I outed at the beginning of the game in the mason pm. I did not think that there would be a traitor and when everyone else said they had mason pms, I got suspicious. If there were any scum in my pm, I would have been killed early in the game.

Who was in your PM with you to start the game?

Me, Ober and DetectableNinja. Dninja never even posted and was killed during the first NP.

Due to this, I find it highly unlikely that Ober is scum.

If it's only you and Ober left then if you died it would be a no-brainer as to who mafia was, since he knew your complete role. They haven't killed you because it would give him away too easily.

They could have killed me later in the game, and they didn't do it. I still had many valuable roles left. If there was scum in my pm, I would not be alive going into DP7

Don't you find it a bit odd that all other pm's have scum but not yours??

Yes. However our mason pm only had three members. Also I don't think TUF would have put a traitor in every pm. It would have been too predictable.

I think we were wrong to assume that every pm would have a traitor...

At 5/28/2012 10:18:57 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 9:03:05 PM, medic0506 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 5:22:26 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:

At 5/28/2012 4:41:21 PM, Buddamoose wrote:

At 5/28/2012 3:52:46 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:
Guys, while I think Ober said something stupid, I doubt he is scum unless he was recently recruited.

I had a powerful role that I outed at the beginning of the game in the mason pm. I did not think that there would be a traitor and when everyone else said they had mason pms, I got suspicious. If there were any scum in my pm, I would have been killed early in the game.

Who was in your PM with you to start the game?

Me, Ober and DetectableNinja. Dninja never even posted and was killed during the first NP.

Due to this, I find it highly unlikely that Ober is scum.

If it's only you and Ober left then if you died it would be a no-brainer as to who mafia was, since he knew your complete role. They haven't killed you because it would give him away too easily.

They could have killed me later in the game, and they didn't do it. I still had many valuable roles left. If there was scum in my pm, I would not be alive going into DP7

Don't you find it a bit odd that all other pm's have scum but not yours??

Yes. However our mason pm only had three members. Also I don't think TUF would have put a traitor in every pm. It would have been too predictable.

I think we were wrong to assume that every pm would have a traitor...

Possibly, but if Ober were left as the only member of the only pm where scum hadn't been found, then he'd be lynched or vig killed, just to eliminate that possibility. This could explain why you haven't been killed.

At 5/28/2012 10:18:57 PM, johnnyboy54 wrote:
Yes. However our mason pm only had three members. Also I don't think TUF would have put a traitor in every pm. It would have been too predictable.

I think we were wrong to assume that every pm would have a traitor...

After thinking about it some more, I don't think we were wrong. I think we were right about there being scum in all pm's, if there isn't then the overall theme of the story doesn't make sense. Scum are the ones that are spread throughout the store, wreaking havoc and getting people fired. It only makes sense that there would be scum in every department, thus every pm.

Also, sorry for saying that you stopped the lynch, it was an assumption on my part because you had mentioned it just a bit before it happened. I guess Tuf must have decided that two dead townies in one day was enough, and went ahead and ended it before another one got lynched.