Debate.org members
Labor Union Debates
Labor Union Debates
History and Debate of Labor Union
A trade union, or as it is sometimes called a labor union, is when a group of workers band together to achieve goals related to their job. Trade Unions are often in the news, especially when they are striking or picketing. However, many people do not know the history behind these organizations, what they do for members and the pros and cons of trade unions.
Trade unions originated in Europe during the industrial revolution. Because of the machinery that had become commonplace, skilled labor became less in demand so employers had nearly all of the bargaining power. Employers mistreated the workers and paid them too little for the work they did. Trade unions were organized that would help in the improvement of working conditions.
The concept of the trade union has evolved over the last one hundred years, but the underlying concept is the same. Union members want their employers to treat them with respect and pay them a fair wage. During the early and middle portions of the twentieth century, laborers were a major force in America and around the world. They have lost some of their influence in the past few decades, mainly because of financial struggles.
The largest union organization in the United States today is AFL-CIO, which has millions of members across the country. What do trade unions do for their members? It varies from union to union, and not every union will offer every type of benefit. Unemployment benefits and insurance are very common benefits and are useful to members in many industries. Collective bargaining and industrial action allow members to negotiate with their employers over wages and working conditions. A final activity that many unions participate in is supporting candidates or lobbying for laws to be passed or repealed.
Public Opinion – Labor Union Debate
With everything the media says about unions, one may wonder if they are good for our economy and business in the United States, or if they cause more harm than good. This is a very good question, and there is no simple answer. Unions can help workers in industries that are regularly underpaid or mistreated. With a union, workers do not have to worry that employers will drastically cut pay or lay off worker with no notice. But, with all of these benefits come some risk, and these risks are what cause criticism of unions by the media.
Unions take the power out of the employer's hands on many issues. There are examples of cases where workers were engaging in sexual or racial harassment, but were protected by their unions and allowed to keep their jobs. Poor workers and excellent workers often receive the same pay and raises, giving no reason for a person to work harder than necessary at their job. Unions can make workplace politics even more complicated. There are a lot of issues to consider when you look at unions. They will likely have a place in certain industries for quite some time; however, they will likely never reach the numbers and influence they held in the early part of the twentieth century.
For Labor Union
Pro
Comment: I'm completely pro-labor, except in cases where companies are being exploited by unions detrimentally such as what happened with some of the automotive companies. Otherwise I am all for workers rights. Though imperfect, the good outweighs the bad.
Comment: Important to protect workers' rights.
Comment: I believe unions are necessary to worker rights, but unions today are becoming abusive in the same way corporations are. They should both be held accountable. It's disturbing that Democrats like Obama try to carve loopholes for unions that they do not for corporations.
Comment: LU is an important tool to leverage the bargaining power of workers. But its power has become corrupted, especially in the case of teacher union. The key here is the dedicated * balance* in bargaining power between the employer and employee - any shift at all is bad, which is usually the case.
Comment: Everyone needs collective bargaining for free from a newly formed Federal Agency. Until the Federal Agency is formed, everyone should be in a union and unions should be in all businesses and everyone should be required to belong, including all white collar workers and everyone on salary. All ‘Employment at Will’ and ‘Right to Work’ laws need to be declared illegal in America with no overriding state laws allowed. No company should be allowed to fire or terminate an employee without a review by an independent board of at least 3 members who would review all documentation and have interviews with the employee and person or person wanting to fire or terminate that employee; then if at least 2 vote in favor of terminating the employee, it is ok to terminate that employee. There would be exceptions e.g., employee comes in threatening to kill or hurt other employees, or destroy company property, etc.
Comment: Opinion varies based on the union and how much power they currently hold.
Comment: I'm for non-government back labor unions. Workers need a way to organize to ensure they are treated well by their employers.
Comment: People have the right to form voluntary organizations
Comment: We need Unions, I just hate that there all run by Communist. and thugs that will destroy your property and possibly kill you if you need to work so bad you will be a scab. Even if your state is a right to work like mine there is basically no way you work without joining the union. It's the only way to not get fired when you dont show up to work during a strike. So your forced to join, pay there dues, and have your hard earned paycheck cut from so it can fund a baby killing democrats run for office. It's not fair. It's wrong, yet what can be done?
Comment: People have a right to organize.
Against Labor Union
Con
Comment: Labor unions were good back in the day, when they actually let you choose to join them or not. Now they force you to join them... So much for workers rights.
Comment: Pro as private organization lacking governmental help. Con as status quo.
Comment: STOP WHINING
Comment: Initial stage of labour union was ok that protected from capitalism behaviour but presently in most cases political propaganda and corrupt union leaders. Results to stall growth
Comment: They do more harm than good. Look at the teacher's unions, depriving children of a education. Or the writer's unions, which caused shows like flavor of love to become popular during the writer's strikes. If the Government does their job to protect th
Comment: Yes on the right to form and join a labor union, no on being forced to join a labor union. Moreover, I do not believe cooperations or labor unions should be allowed to contribute to political campaigns.
Comment: No one should be forced or harassed into joining a union or paying its dues. I am totally against public sector unions because they often waste time and resources on the taxpayers' dime.
Comment: Radically corrupt and a business destroyers. We need right-to-work and other legislation like it to stop these monsters.
Comment: There's a fine line between helping the employees, and screwing the employers. The unions have served their purpose, now they just steal money. The jobs ultimately belong to the employer, not the union. I support laws that improve the work place, obviously we don't want to go back to the way things were 100 years ago, but we don't need these blood sucking leaches called workers unions to accomplish these laws.
Comment: Voluntary unions. Usually harms American competitiveness and leads to job losses.

