There's no doubt that "Frosty the Snowman" is tired and overplayed. While the song is culturally significant, it has become dull in the minds of many music fans and lovers of Christmas. Grace VanderWaals did a great job exploring the nostalgia of this song while breathing fresh life into it.
Frosty the Snowman is a song that nearly every child knows growing up. At this point, it can be considered a modern carol. As long as Grace feels that she did her best, then I don't see why anyone should feel unhappy about her cover. Singing is about having fun and being entertaining.
Yes, Grace VanderWaals cover of Frosty the Snowman did the song justice. Grace did an unusual rendition of the song that fit her style. She didn't change the words or the melody, but added her own unusual pauses and unique raspy voice. This is something many artists do, especially in Christmas songs. She was dead on.
Yes, the Grace VanderWaals cover did the song justice because she has a beautiful voice. Singing well is fun to do. Frosty the Snowman is a fun song that just celebrates Christmas. People should be encouraged to make new covers because they make Christmas songs better. She did a wonderful job.