Do you find chants such as the Hare Krishna mantra to be meditative (yes) or simply repetitive and methodical (no)?

  • It is meditative

    It allows you to relax and to get into a meditative trance. So that you can get into touch with yourself. You will be able to connect to your higher power. Now Doctor's are say this is something that each of us should do because it can extend our lives.

  • Yes, with a bit of no

    Meditiation needs not be etched in stone. This is because when one meditates, there are those that find it easy, and those that find it hard. The repetition and methodic nature may be a "level 1", like an infant or child learning to speak. "Level 2" may be the ability to reach the subconscious.

  • Repetition Aids Meditation

    Repetitive chants help increase meditative states. Focusing on such things like breathing or the same sounds over and over help let minds wander and drift into nothingness. That nothingness is where the meditative state comes from. In that emptiness, the mind can be filled with whatever messages it needs from the universe.

  • They have a musical component.

    Yes, I find chants such as the Hare Krishna mantra to be meditative, because they have a musical component to them that are entrancing. Hare Krishna has a ring to it, and it draws people in. Because it attracts the listener and distracts them, it is not just repetitive and methodical, but it has a meditative component to it.

  • No, Hare Krishna chants are not meditative.

    I do not find the Hare Krishna mantra to be useful in meditation. I have tried it several times and have found that it is more a nuisance than anything else. In fact, for me, repeating a mantra tends to make me focus more on the mantra itself, making it a complete distraction. It becomes repetitive but that's about all it does.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
kbub says2014-02-14T03:21:09.310
Mutually exclusive? I say yes to both.