It's my belief, gained from reading many of the different versions of the Bible, that Lucifer's largest point in the argument with God was the fact that He would forgive the human race for anything as long as they repented. However, His first Sons and Daughters - The Angels - could do nothing to gain His forgiveness when They sinned. So Lucifer, in his argument believed that he could do better than God and said so, causing God to give him the opportunity to do so.
Thus, Hell was created.
Now I believe that Hell is just Lucifer's way of stating "You must truly Know and Understand remorse for what you have done, before you can gain an entrance to Heaven's Gate."
As any true intellectual will inform you, there can be no TRUE understanding without personal experience, and we all know how good a teacher Suffering can be.
Not only is this not directly supported by any scriptures, but it also contradicts the scriptural messages.
I would like to see what scriptures you would use in a back-handed way to support this reasoning and am also curious as to if you are aware of the contradictions to scripture that would arise from this reasoning.
There is a lot you have to assume in order for that argument to work, and since no description of hell is in the Old or New Testaments according to religious scholar Phillip Jenkins you cannot argue hell exists from any biblical perspective, but lets take a step back and assume your not talking about any Abrahamic religion, and just god and the afterlife in general, using fire "as a symbol of rebirth" is a faulty analogy, maybe fire is a sign of ultimate destruction, ultimately one cannot compare advanced metaphysical concepts like hell by comparing them to fire an earthly phenomena for there is nothing on earth the compares to the hinterworld.
The scripture says "the eternal lake of fire". It's forever, it doesn't end. It's not that you burn once and it's all over. You can't go back it's "eternal separation" from God. You won't be feeling remorse. Only regret and gnashing of the teeth. Eternal damnation. No going back for you.