Yes, judicial review is appropriate in HADOPI, because it is always important to make sure that the music producers are not abusing the avenues of enforcement in HADOPI. There are also exceptions and special situations, and having a judge review these rules is important to tailor remedies to each individual situation.
Yes, judicial review is appropriate in HADOPI, because it is important to make sure that the antipiracy laws are not abused. It is also important to make sure that they are enforced in a fair manner. France's position on antipiracy is laudable, and a graduated response is appropriate, but judicial review for abuses is always helpful.