"Now that so much gold is found, a dispute arises as to which brings more profit, whether to go about robbing or to go to the mines. A hundred castellanos are as easily obtained for a woman as for a farm, and there are plenty of dealers who go about looking for girls; those from nine to ten are now in demand, and for all ages a good price must be paid." Columbus wrote this!
Columbus Day is national holiday which many people celebrate and enjoy. What are we celebrating, though? A brave man who discovered new lands? Or a liar who tortured thousands of Native Americans and sparked something that killed millions more? Should Columbus Day be a national holiday? I’m here to prove that we shouldn’t be celebrating a man who not only failed his mission, but didn’t stop his men from killing Native Americans while asking them to do the impossible.
Columbus definitely shouldn’t be celebrated in a holiday because he didn’t stop his men from killing Native Americans (yes, he technically didn’t kill them himself, but it was almost as bad) and that led to-and most likely sparked-the genocide of millions of Native Americans. That’s nothing to celebrate; we can’t just blindly celebrate him with ignoring everything else he did that was bad. In fact, Adolf Hitler expected the extermination of the Jews (which obviously didn’t happen) to be similar to the (almost) extermination of the Native Americans.
And even if for some reason you can justify the horrible actions Columbus did, you still can’t turn a blinds eye to the fact that he didn’t even discover the Americas. Leif Erickson was the first European (Viking) who discovered America, centuries before Columbus did. What are we really celebrating if a) he didn’t stop the killing and torturing of hundreds of thousands of Native Americans while bringing over dangerous diseases such as Syphilis, and b) he didn’t discover the Americas while failing his mission?
Some people might argue that Columbus Day is about the beginning of exploration and the trade of cultures, ideas, and goods between Native Americans and Europeans. But, ask yourself what happened after the trade of cultures, goods, and ideas. Was it all happy?...No, definitely not. What Columbus sparked was NOT the beginning of a newfound relationship between Native Americans and Europeans where they peacefully worked together. Ninety percent of Native Americans died and those who remained were forced into tiny reserves. Also, people could say that we wouldn’t be here without Columbus and he discovered the Earth wasn’t round. If Columbus didn’t come to the Americas, someone else most certainly would have. To counter the latter, Eratosthenes is the Greek philosopher who is credited for discovering the world is round and Aristotle argued in his writings that the Earth is round centuries before Columbus.
In conclusion, Columbus Day should most certainly not be celebrated and at least be changed to Leif Erikson Day or Indigenous People Day. Columbus didn’t think twice of his men killing and torturing Native Americans, tried to force upon them a new religion, brought over deadly diseases, sparked something that killed ninety percent of Native Americans, and failed his mission.
Columbus sold people into slavery, raped, and killed for monetary gain and sport. How on earth could people in good conscience celebrate a holiday for a human that did these things. Also the fact that the holiday was created by the Knights of Columbus on because they wanted to have a holiday for a Catholic is just ridiculous and the way they pushed it through and made it a national holiday is just a travesty.
Why on God's green earth would we choose to glorify a man who mercilessly slaughtered and dehumanized the native people? He encouraged his men to rape the native women, some as young as nine years old. He punished the natives' minor offenses by slicing off their noses and ears. He forced these people to find him gold regularly, and if they failed, their hands were cut off. How could you ever celebrate a holiday for a person so evil and cruel?
Christopher Columbus, first of all, didn't discover the Americas. There were people here for upward of 20,000 years before his arrivals. The first Europeans to find the Americas were the Norseman of modern day Scandinavia. And Christopher Columbus was a brutal piece of work. He used to hang 12 Indians at a time; 1 for Jesus and 12 for his apostles.
He is the man credited with"discovering" the land we call home during a brutal age of exploration. Forgive the man his treatment of the locals, as they was how uncivilized peoples were treated in that day and age. We've come a long way since then. The Spanish, the French, the Dutch were equally as brutal. Do we ban Presidents Day because Washington and Jefferson had slaves? How about Halloween because of it's "evil" origins? I say enough with the political correctness.
Several hundred years AFTER Columbus, the treatment of American Indians got even worse. Should Columbus shoulder the blame for this? What about the little explored pocket of history where the U.S., during our own "Imperial Age", took over Hawaii by force and brutally claimed land in the Far East (see Philippines)? Should we give back Hawaii?
Appreciate that in 1492 Columbus set out to find a passage to India and stumbled upon our land. Since then we've had our ups and downs, have overcome many of our shortcomings (slavery, women's suffrage, etc.) and have the opportunity to continually improve by learning from our shortcomings and mistakes.
I think we ought to be allowed to celebrate Columbus and his accomplishments. The Italians should be allowed to. It's their hero and their day. They should be allowed to enjoy it. Should we ban Andrew Jackson from being celebrated? Last time I checked he is a better canidate for banning than Hitler or Mussolini or Columbus.
There is nothing wrong with celebrating Columbus Day. Christopher Columbus was a key explorer in the 'Age of Exploration'. He did what he set out to do, which was to find a western sea route from Europe. However, that does not mean there is any need to forget the fact that many Native Americans died after he landed in the New World.
It is my opinion that it is not wrong to celebrate Columbus Day. By celebrating this holiday people are celebrating the fact that the "new world" was discovered by Columbus, and that this paved the way for the country that is now in place. Celebrating this holiday is not the same as celebrating the violence that was committed to establish the current nation.
We all know that he discovered Haiti and the Dominican and the USA was just a myth. When he came to Colombia where he also found he killed of the people because the Spaniard said there was gold in the ground. He turned the people of Colombia into sex-slaves and sent them back to Spain. Even thought he was brutal and a perv, he is a reason for us Italian to stay up all night, have parades and get drunk. If the Irish do it for a Saint were doing it for him!