Amazon.com Widgets
  • They are one and the same,

    There is no such thing as "gender fluid" or "transgender" or "intersex" or whatever pronoun you crazy people choose for any particular day. You can certainly BELIEVE that you are these things. But believing does not make it so. Believing in something DOES NOT make it actually real. You are born with specific chromosomes that can NEVER be changed, no matter how many surgeries you have.

    You can't just make up whatever you want just because you feel unhappy with your body or who you are. Gender is clearly defined by your DNA. And your feelings don't change that.

    So yes, sex and gender are the same thing. Because there are actually only two genders: male and female.

  • Wow, a lot of people have a deluded idea of what gender is.

    Gender is not a social construct. Our society doesn't understand how being louder doesn't make you more right. Sex and gender are one and the same. Biology has never found a difference in them. Rose is a rose is a rose is a rose is a rose. I am really amazed how people don't get it.

  • Yes because science.

    Your want for sex and gender to be different is no reflection on what it actually is any more than your want for a god to exist is a method to verify it's existence. Most of the arguments for the differentiation are from transexuals. Transexuality is NOT the same as homosexuality. It is not genetic. It is labeled in psychology as gender identity dysphoria. Stop being ignorant.

  • I doesn't make sense to me anymore!

    I just don't know when sex and gender stopped meaning the same thing. I've always been tomboyish. I've never heard of women being expected to do certain things while men are to do others. I always thought that men and women were supposed to support their families. I thought both genders or sexes or whatever it is now, were supposed to cook, clean, be gentle, be strong, be amazing.

    I see some of the definitions of gender provided by those who say no and what they say are that I'm not who I think I am. I like sports, mud, cars, racing, "guy things", but I still say I'm a girl. So, to society am I a disillusioned man with a vagina?

  • Sex is one definition of gender

    There is no argument, really. The dictionary answers the question, it's not an opinion. It's quite simple - sex, as in biological sex, is one definition of gender. So yes, they can mean the same thing, and I even started on the "yes" side of this. But the question is - "Is sex the same as gender?" Well, obviously no, because although they share one definition, gender has definitions that go way beyond sex, and is very complex. Yes, I can ask for the gender of an animal and expect the answer to be the biological sex of that animal, but since other definitions of gender don't overlap with the definition of sex, they are not the same.

  • Sex is one definition of Gender

    There is no argument. It is in dictionaries. One definition of Gender is Sex, as in biological sex. Gender has many more meanings, including the roles of the sexes, and is very complex, so I would say sex and gender are not the same, but they overlap at biological sex.

  • Of course it is

    No matter how one feels about themselves and how they choose to identify, if the person has a penis they are a male and if they have a vagina they are a female. It is scientifically proven that they are the same thing no matter what one decides to say.

  • This isn't a misogyny issue or any kind of oppression issue.

    This isn't a misogyny issue or any kind of oppression issue, although, it can be used as such in order to oppress, or be perceived as oppression. Let's be real here; the amount of people who push any agenda to suppress gender equality, or specifically in this case, transgender/transvestite people, isn't very significant, but it certainly does exist. Quintessentially, it's a semantics issue (communication issue). When you fill out a form for health insurance, or if you're registering for a gender specific sport, male and female biology is very important.

    If you add an additional meaning or replace the meaning of the word gender, confusion and legal issues would ensue.

    I think when it comes to addressing a person, they should be addressed in the way they want to be identified. But because you identify in a philosophical sense or a subjective sense as a certain gender, it does not actually make you that gender. If a giraffe wants to be a gopher(it wants to be something other than itself), that doesn't make it a gopher. However, humans can now undergo surgery and treatments to change their gender for the most part. I would say that a man who replaces his genitals with female genitals, and undergoes hormone therapy, is pretty close to being a woman. It's not very black in white, as there are more things one may be able to do to become more of a certain gender in the future with improvements in technology/medicine, but that person is now a woman more so than he(she) is a man. I would round up, so to speak, and accept that biologically "he" is now a "she".

    Long story short, it would be conflicting/contradicting to include/replace a subjective/philosophical definition with a word that is rooted in scientific fact. We need separate definitions for these things. Biology is important, as well as one's own subjective experience, but let's keep them separate. Emotion has no place in the scientific method, and for good reason. If you feel you're mentally the opposite gender, you can identify as the opposite gender if that's what you want. But until you undergo gender transformative surgery, your body is your body. You have every right to not subscribe to societal norms, but changing the definition of scientific terms to fit a subjective context is contradicting and inefficient, and therefore irrational. Gender's attachment to certain words in certain languages is mostly unnecessary, too, but those languages were created during unscientific times.

    If I want to know if you're biologically male/female, and I also want to know what sex you philosophically subscribe to for your identity, I can't ask you, "So what is your gender? Okay, and what is your gender?". It doesn't work. You're not going to successfully change the meaning of the word "gender".

    I think there should be a term for gender identity, though. It would be more efficient to have a word for that. Gender identity works just fine for now though, I think.

  • Its All The Same

    In life, people will accept that something can mean something else if it supports their point of view. Everyone wants to feel better about themselves. Everyone wants to feel that what they do is right, moral, decent, nothing to be ashamed of. So those who say NO, are doing so because a few people decided gender is a philosophical representation. This is not the case at all. Gender is simply a PC term for the word Sex. Male, and female...That is it. The transgender agenda, which has become pop culture, is their own worst enemy. When a man, decides to have surgery, wear women's clothing, and take hormonal pills, its not simply to become feminine, it's to become a woman, that's the whole point in that persons view. Therefore, gender and sex are one in the same.

  • Its All The Same

    In life, people will accept that something can mean something else if it supports their point of view. Everyone wants to feel better about themselves. Everyone wants to feel that what they do is right, moral, decent, nothing to be ashamed of. So those who say NO, are doing so because a few people decided gender is a philosophical representation. This is not the case at all. Gender is simply a PC term for the word Sex. Male, and female...That is it. The transgender agenda, which has become pop culture, is their own worst enemy. When a man, decides to have surgery, wear women's clothing, and take hormonal pills, its not simply to become feminine, it's to become a woman, that's the whole point in that persons view. Therefore, gender and sex are one in the same.

  • Two Different Things

    Sex describes biological differences, both in the genotype and phenotype. Gender is a social construct whereby society creates roles to be played by individuals dependent upon their sex. For instance, Western society assumes that individuals of the male sex will assume masculine gender roles (ie, playing with cars) while individuals of the female sex will take on feminine roles (ie, playing with dolls).

  • Sex and Gender are Different.

    Those who have answered yes to this have completely ignored the existence of transexual people. This is understandable because the vast majority of people have male or female genitalia and then feel like a male or female in their head - but it is extremely close-minded to think that these are the only options.

  • Sex is objective, Gender is subjective.

    Sex a noun is based on the function a reproductive organ plays in the reproduction of a species. Many species like mammals on earth have two sexes, one sex carries eggs while the other carries cells containing genetic material which is used to fertilize an egg or eggs. Where as examples of species on earth that have one sex and have the ability reproduce from a single organism are single celled organism, fungi and plants.
    Gender is subjective between different cultural norms and has referred to the role of the individual in a society or collective and are based around the binary sex of the human species. Historically, different cultures on earth had different kinds and numbers of genders, four genders being the norm in some Native American cultures which would be based on two sexes and two roles they would play in that society. Two genders being the norm in many cultures heavily influenced by bronze age mythology in each sex only had one role to play in those societies. In some technologically developed societies in the early 21st century, gender is used more as a means of self identification and less so as a role the individual has in that society, however it still plays a role in people's appearance and behavior.

  • Lol no. Just no

    Go to Google. Type in "Gender definition". Read it. Now, type in "sex definition" and don't look at the one that talks about intercourse. Look at the one that talks about what you are physically. That is my argument. No stupid stuff. No logic crap. Just definitions. That is all.

  • Learn your definitions and there wouldn't be a debate.

    Point blank, sex is biological (male, female, intersex) and gender is the social construct of what it means to be that sex (masculine, feminine). In every society there are different gender roles. In every time period there are different gender roles. Who are typically care givers? Women. Who are typically construction workers? Men. Who are the typical breadwinners (although this is currently changing)? Men. Hunting is seen as a more masculine sport/hobby and so the males are typically the ones who do it now. If you look at different societies in places like Africa, women are often seen gathering the food or hunting. So no, sex and gender is not the same thing. This is not even something that is debatable.

  • Sex is genitals, Gender is a spectrum

    A person born with female sex organs may be female in sex, but their gender doesn't mean that the are female. Look to transgender people, a person with female genitals doesn't constitute that they identify as female, transgender people identify as a different gender, not cisgender. While it is in every respect that gender and sex are the same scientifically, that doesn't mean it's okay to call someone who wants to be called he, she because they were born female.

  • No, gender and sex are not the same.

    Gender is a social construct propagated by society to define people based on stereotypical roles and feature that have come to be expected from men, women, boys and girls. Sex, on the other hand, is a biological concept based on biological features, such as genitalia or chromosomes. It is totally plausible for a person with one set of chromosomes to feel and act as though they are a particular gender that may be thought of, by society, as being opposite to their sex.

  • Sex is biological, gender is an idea/philosophy.

    There are two sexes, but 63 different official identities people can use to identify themselves as. Everyone is born with either a penis or a vagina, which is their (biological) sex. But gender is self-identity that may be different from what one was born as. This identity thing personally make no sense to me, but apparently a lot of people aren't satisfied with what they were born as. Sex is biological, gender is personal.

  • Is it lacking understanding? Or is it an unwillingness to accept? Perhaps it is both.

    Those who consider that there is no such thing as intersexed or transgender because you believe one is created with specific chromosomes that made you who you actually are, consider these facts:
    - There are women born with female genitals who has XY genes.
    - There are men born with male genitals who has XX genes.
    - There are people with XXY or XXXY or XXYY and other genetic defects that you cannot account for their sex entirely if you define sex as chromosome based. Some of these people develop transgender tendencies, but there are a good percentage who does not.
    - If sex and gender is one and all the same, people with birth defects having genitalia of both sexes would be unclassifiable.
    - Transgender tendencies appeared to be related to the hormones in a developing baby at her mother's womb at specific times. It does not seem to be specifically related to the X or Y chromosomes though little was done to explore other genes that may increase the likelihood of the condition.

    Those who do not act accordingly to their gender sterotypes - that is fine. You still identify yourself as an not-typical male/female according to your sex and be pround and lead a happy life, and that is great. But there are people who is unable to feel at ease with their gender. If you are forced to wear that pair of shoes you hate every day, what will you do? You find ways not to wear it.

    Gender dysphoria as a psychological condition is very valid, but how you treat it is what people debate about the most. Claiming sex and gender is one and all the same and denying the existence of the condition is essentially to avoid needing to address this problem in those individuals.

  • Myths about sex and gender

    Sex is genitals and love. Gender is the idenity spectrum. There are male, female, and intersex as biological sexes. Gender does not match sex. Theres no such thing as transsexual except transgender. Do not label transgender as transsexual because its very offensive to transgenders. Intersex is not a condition. Intersex is a biologicsl sex with mixed genitals. Sex and gender are not the same thing.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
cca494 says2015-10-18T23:13:25.063
I don't understand. What IS sex?