Amazon.com Widgets

Oilers send prime forward, Taylor Hall to the Devils for defenseman, Adam Larsson. Is the trade as lopsided as it seems in favor of the Devils?

Oilers send prime forward, Taylor Hall to the Devils for defenseman, Adam Larsson. Is the trade as lopsided as it seems in favor of the Devils?
  • Yes, the trade is lopsided

    The recent trade involving the Devils not only appears lopsided, but is objectively lopsided. The Devils received a player of greater value than they lost, coming out ahead of their trade partner. This might not seem fair, but should be allowed because as long as both teams agree on the trade, it should be seen as fair to the governing body (the league).

  • Yes, it seems so

    Still not sure what impact this will have on Oilers. They are not close to being a playoff team anyway, so I'm not sure any trade they make at this point can be termed "bad", but I do know that this should really help the Devils. Taylor Hall will flourish in an easier conference and with a team that is closer to being "playoff caliber."

  • The trade of Hall for Larsson does not seem even

    Taylor Hall is a first round draft pick; Larsson was chosen 4th overall. Hall had 328 points in 381 Oilers' games. Larssons's stats don't really stand out. The Oilers need stronger defense; that is why the Oilers picked up Larsson. Teams recruit according to need. Yet, a prime forward is always a more valuable asset than a defenseman. Hall is now one of the highest paid forwards. Forwards are versatile in that they play defensively as well. In all, the trade does seem to favor the Devils. The Devils made a smart move. Hall will make a significant contribution to the Oilers team.

  • Who can judge the workings of sport?

    First and foremost, this is NHL hockey, so it seems unlikely to matter to most of the general population. Second, while the trade is lopsided, there are almost always reasons unseen that make the trade of equal value. Some may recall in the late 1990's when the Cleveland Browns were reborn, the 49ers sent several players for 'consideration' in trade. That meant the 49ers needed to clear salary cap space to save the players they actually wanted on the roster.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.