Amazon.com Widgets

One of the reasons for the Electoral College is because James Madison was worried about the "tyranny of the majority,"in which a majority places its own interests above those of a minority group. Is the electoral college outdated?

One of the reasons for the Electoral College is because James Madison was worried about the "tyranny of the majority,"in which a majority places its own interests above those of a minority group. Is the electoral college outdated?
  • Undemocratic relic should be relegated to scrap heap of history

    The current system is totally undemocratic. Millions of Americans, from conservatives in California or liberals in Utah don't really have a voice in a national election. Win a state by 1 vote is equal to winning it by 500,00. How is that fair?
    It's been 230 years since the Founding, it's okay to change some things.

  • Yes, the Electoral College is outdated.

    The Electoral College now seems to inhibit the natural election process because of the loopholes candidates use in the primaries in order to become their party's nominee. There is a lot of scrutiny on whether or not the Electoral College is an honest part of our election process. There should at least be some deliberation on changing the structure of the electoral college.

  • No, the electoral college is not outdated.

    The principles behind James Madison supporting the Electoral College are not outdated. The tyranny of the majority is becoming a real concern for many Americans. More Americans are being supported by government programs, while fewer are being asked to contribute to these programs. Americans that do pay taxes, are being outvoted by those that receive government benefits. Therefore, a growing majority of people dependent on government are voting for politicians who take away money from others.

  • No, it is not outdated.

    The electoral college is not outdated. Tyranny of the majority may not be the best or it may not be always right. This is because it will always outdo the minority who may not have a chance to table their grievances. I also agree with James Madison and believe that the Electoral college is fair and its not outdated either.

  • The small states still support it.

    People in rural communities have different interests than people in cities. It would be a shame if America declined because the people in cities ganged up and took resources from the people in rural communities. It's important to make sure that each group has their say, even if that means smaller communities have more of a say. By the same logic, the Senate would be outdated, too.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.