Amazon.com Widgets

Should Heidi Klum be the 4th judge on Americas Got Talent?

Asked by: LindaMc
  • Why shouldn't she?

    Why should somebody be discriminated against when she wants to judge a competition? If the show will let her, she should have a full right to go on without a whole entire group of people go against her and stopping her from doing what she wants. Let her on the show.

  • Yes she should

    Why not? She is just as capable as anyone else and easy on the eyes. If you don't like the talent you can at least hope for someone interesting doing the judging. I think if you give her a chance she will prove to be a great judge. Anyone think different?

  • Heidi is horrible!

    I can't understand what qualifications Heidi has to be judging musicians or any other type of performer. She has no talent or knowledge, and she shows it every time she speaks to judge the acts. I honestly switched the channel because I find her extremely annoying. Very bad choice for a talent show judge; makes a mockery of the program premise.

  • How can you judge talent if you have none?

    Good looks go a long way, but she has no intelligence. Never even started college, no brain. Just a hose bag. All looks just clueless. Pretty poor role model as models go. She should sell diet coke. Dentine gum. Work the street. But judge talent? So many many better more options for judges.

  • No Heidi Klum should not be the 4th judge on Americas Got Talent.

    I personally like Heidi Klum but I do not think she will be a factor on Americas Got Talent. I think Howard Stern, Howie Mandell and Mel B would be better off without her. Out of the four I am only a fan of Howard Stern, but I still will not watch the show.

  • Why, because she has big breasts?


    A more important question is: why are retarded shows like “America’s Got Talent,” “Dancing With the Stars,” and “Project Runway” even allowed to be on TV.
    ===================================================================================
    We are turning into a nation of mush heads.
    It is bad enough that we have to endure 3 seasons of sports (Baseball, Football, and basketball) 24-7.
    To save our nation, we need many more educational programs put on TV to replace most of the junk like mentioned above and sports 24-7.

  • She doesn't have the eyes of one

    Heidi picks horrible golden buzzers and doesn't see the contestants as a professional judge. She says the most basic things ever and usually just goes with whatever she likes or what the judges choose. By far, Heidi Klum is the worst judge on AGT and I think she should be replaced.

  • Just not a good fit...

    She just doesn't have much to add to almost every performance, regardless of what the performer is presenting. No critiques or personal feelings, actually she usually repeats what the previous judge has just said, almost verbatim. Nothing against her, but they could find better undoubtedly. Someone that can bring in some subject matter expertise at least in one area.

  • She’s a model.

    All the other judges have backgrounds in music or comedy or are full time judges. Heidi Klum has a background in modeling. That’s it. Unless one of the auditions is how well someone can pose, she really doesn’t have reason to be there. I know anybody can appreciate whether somebody’s singing is good or bad, but if we use that logic, why her in particular? All in all, her being the fourth judge has never really made sense to me.

  • Model and mom..Thats it

    She has been a successful model. She appears to be a great mom, working positively together with Seal.
    That is not a sufficient skill set to determine if someone has enough true talent to make a career of it. And Mel B, I had to google her to find out her history.

  • No talent. SAD

    Being a model takes almost zero talent (just good genetics). She isn't even american either. SAD. She is an embarrassment to judges in all sports/events everywhere (olympics, WSL, etc.) She would be a better host (Tyra Banks is talentless AND annoying). Bring back howard stern. Baba Booey!!! Simon and Howie the only qualified judges on the show currently

  • Can't stand her judgment

    She speaks nonsense. Watched AGT for 5 seasons now, and she is the worst judge by far. I fast forward whenever she speaks because I can't stand her comments. She simply doesn't have qualifications to judge, except perhaps if it was a modeling contest. And not even to speak of the endless cliches she's spouting.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.