Amazon.com Widgets

Should Silesia be its own independent country apart from Poland?

  • Yes, it should be.

    If the people and government of Silesia want to be free from Poland, they should be allowed to do so. There shouldn't be any debate over stuff like this. It's like Scotland. If they wish to be free from Britain, they should be allowed to do so. It's a new time.

  • We are not Slav's

    My farther,s land is my fartherland which can be traced back to 13th century, yes 700 years and we have never classed ourselves as being German or Polish , being Germanic does not make you a German. We are silesian's with a proud history, our own language, folklore, customs, dress , cuisine and more importantly the land belongs to the people not the numerous conquests for the minerals that can be found on our lands, which is the main reason why the poles have no intention of even a mere recognition of our separate identity. Don,t take my word on this, as it is all documented history. Why should the Poles recognise us as they will not accept their part in the genocide and the ethnic cleansing that took place 5 million people ( Upper Silesia ) forced to leave their homes, mostly women and children, who had to walk to a foreign land (Germany) WE WILL RETURN

    Gerhard

  • They have a different language!

    All peoples with a separate language should be independent. Silesia and Moravia should both be independent. And how about Kashubia? In ancient days Silesia was an independent country, but they were conquered by Poland. If they wish to regain their independence, they should be allowed to do so. Aspirant peoples should be free.

  • Yes it should be

    I am of Silesian-German descent. It should have never been taken from Germany in the first place, because the land had been German for centuries. However, as a result of the ethnic cleansing that occurred in the years after The Second World War, the land can no longer be described as German, but at the same time, Poland, regardless of the current demographics is not and will never be Silesia's rightful owner. Given that the truly native non-German Silesian still have an enormous prescence in upper Silesia, an insufficient number of Germans that would be needed to justify german annexation, and that Poland is occupying that doesn't truly belong to them, independence I believe is the best option.

  • Yes, they are their own people.

    I have Silesian ancestry. My maternal great grandfather was born there in the mid-1800s, and was very proud of it. He didn' t consider himself to be Polish, Czech, German, Austrian, or Slovak. His native language was Silesian.

    According to the 2011 official census in Poland, about over half a million people declared Silesian as their native language. Silesia has for centuries been dominated by their neighbors. This is the 21st Century, not the 18th. The eras of empire are over. It's time for Silesians to have their own independence.

  • Yes it should.

    I feel that Silesia should be its own independent country apart from Poland because they have different beliefs and ideals than the rest of Poland. Anytime this happens it is perfectly fine for a country to become independent from the country it was apart of. It happens quite a bit!

  • Silesia is better off in Poland

    Despite the fact that Silesia contains most of Poland's coal industry, it would be hard for an independent Silesia to survive by itself, and would still need to heavily rely on its neighbors, especially Poland and the Czech Republic. Why fix something that's not broken? Why the Silesian people are certainly their own people, it is still part of Poland. If all the Silesians want independence, which is doubtful, just grant them autonomy, like Scotland.

  • Silesia is fine being a part of Poland

    Silesia has something of a national identity, but it is still part of the Polish nation. The recent trend of provinces wanting independence around Europe is unnerving. The purpose for these moves out of a nation and into independence may be attributed to regions that want more votes in the UN. If Silesia gains sovereignty, how often would they not vote parallel to Poland?

  • Keep it together

    No, they need to stay attached and under Poland, and if they decided to become their own country they would probably regret it. It takes a long time to establish a country, and they have no need to since they have a lot of power already inside of Poland as it is.

  • Poland is unified.

    No, Silesia should not be its own independent country apart from Poland, because Poland needs unity to provide strength. Poland has been through a great deal of turmoil in its modern history. With so much conflict, additional division would not likely serve Poland's best interests. They are stronger the larger they are.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.