I am someone in an extension class (A top class) and I am enjoying it! For the person who said "Groupinb by academic ability is impractical" your statement is not true at all! Everyone in my class is the same year! We are talking about grouping by age THEN ability. This year I learnt so much, my grades have improved heaps because I am not limited by the students who struggle more in school.
I think that kids should be grouped by ability because it allows students to progress at there own speed. Some grown ups or students think its a bad idea to get grouped by ability is because they dont want to be in a real;ly hard or easy classroom. So thats why im saying yes you should get grouped by ability
Yes students will get bored because they have already learned what the teacher is teaching. Yes the student can help a lower level student. But the higher level student is not getting the proper education they need to be successful in their mind. Yes grouping students by ability should be allowed in school.
There is no reason to not group students by their academic ability. They must be tested, then placed in schools according to their results.
Once placed, they have the opportunity to rise in classes, getting into the more prestigious classes if they are capable of beating those students in virtual combat.
You see, the top class will have the best supplies and equipment, and the lowest will have little more than cardboard boxes for their desks.
It's a perfect system, as seen in this documentary: http://en.Wikipedia.Org/wiki/Baka_and_Test
Kids may be learning about the gross PDH in 5th or 6th grade and the little kids will be laughing and complaining the whole time. Then kids will tell their parents and the parents might clothe Police and the school will be shut down for teaching inappropriate things to such little minds! We don't want that happening do we?
Loll lol loo lolollo lol o l ollololoo ol o olo lo lo lo lo lo l lo lo lo lo ol ol ol o oo o o lo olo lo o o lo lo lo lo l olo lo lo lol o olol ol ol ol olo lo ol oolol
N n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n no
I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SA NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY NO I SAY no I SAY NO I SAY NO!!!!!!
Putting all 9 years olds or 12 year olds in the same group is easy to do. We know their age. We don't know jall of their abilities, though. We can know a reading level, or their score on a test, but it's really hard to have all that data for every single child in the United States and then group kids appropriately.
There are also problems with it. What is life like when you're a 14 year old kid in a class of 10 year olds? What about the 10 year old in a class of 14 year olds? Kids need to be around kids of similar ages to learn social skills.