Amazon.com Widgets
  • Yes they should....

    Juveniles are almost adults; they have the capability of acting like adults. A crime is a crime, no matter who commits the crime the victim’s family still suffers. Many teenagers have personal problems but that does not mean they have to committee a crime to feel better, they just need to search for help. As well as adults, teenager should be punished the same way because if they don’t they won’t regret what they did.

  • Teens should be tried as adults because they are old enough to be responsible for their actions.

    Teens should be tried as adults. All teens know that killing is wrong. If they aren't tried as adults teens will think that crimes are okay and continue to commit them. Also, teens today don't fear the law because teens don't think they will get caught. Teens are old enough to be responsible for their actions.

  • Adult crimes deserve adult punishment.

    If teenagers are mature enough to make the choice to commit an adult crime then they should be treated like an adult when it comes to the punishment. If a teen can make an adult decision to break the law, they should receive a sentence that fits the severity of the crime.

  • Teens should be tried as adults...

    Because they know right from wrong by this time.. They are considered "old enough" to make life changing decisions in school, and they are old enough to live on their own by 16. Why shouldn't they be held accountable for their actions? If they are old enough to decide what they want to do with their own life, they are old enough to understand that they could be changing someone else's by committing a crime; especially murder. All kids, from a young age, understand that murder is wrong.

  • Yes

    If they commit an adult crime than they should be tried like an adult. A long time ago I was taught that if you want to hang out with the big dogs than you need to get off the porch. Meaning if you have the thought process to make those decisions than you better be ready for the results of them.

  • I am a teen

    I am a teen myself and I am fully capable of grasping the gravity of my actions. I am aware that if I commit a crime punishment will follow. At my school I can already tell who is going to get themselves into the juvenile system, if not the adult system. They're the teens who lack respect for the law and think being caught is not possible. These teens, my fellow classmates, should be punished if they commit a crime. I know they can think for themselves. They know the law, but disregard it anyway. So I say, yes, if they commit a crime deserving of punishment on the adult system they should be tried as an adult.

  • Yes they should be tried as adults.

    Teenagers should stop being stupid and retarded individuals. They need to act their age and yeah, so if a teen comes and shoots up my house I will want them to be tried as an adult because if you can do an adult crime you can do the adult time.

  • Why should they get a pass?

    Why should teens get a pass for their actions? There shouldn't be any distinction between teens and adults. You commit a crime you pay the price, it is that simple. And what about justice for the victims family or even the victim? Why should they suffer by not seeing justice based on the age of the criminal?

  • Yes in Most Cases

    Yes, teenagers should be tried as adults, in some cases. When a teenager commits a violent crime, he or she should be tried as an adult. Any teenager that commits a crime that results in death or physical harm to an individual should automatically be tried as an adult. Teenagers are aware of right and wrong – they are aware that death is real and irreversible. By making a decision to commit a crime that results in death or harm to an individual, that teenager is no longer an innocent child.

  • Teenagers should be tried as adults

    If they don't get treated as harshly they may think they can keep getting away with things. Think about all the young people in the Vancouver riot, they broke in to stores, they stole, they even set a police car on fire. That's why I think they should be treated the same.

  • I believe that teens should’t be tried as adults

    I don’t believe teens should go to jail because their brains arena’t fully developed; well actually it’s a fact that your brain sin’t fully developed until you’re 25 years-old. The prefrontal cortex is the part of the brain that weighs outcomes, forms judgments, and control impulses and emotions. Scientists found that the prefrontal cortex is immature in teenagers compared to adults (until fully developed). Studies have shown that teenagers’ mental energy (in making decisions) is in the back of the brain, whereas adults do their processing in the front. Adult brains are wired to notice errors in decision-making better, but a teenager wouldn't’t notice any error.
    The nucleus accumbens is a part that is developed in a teenager’s brain. It is the part of the brain that seeks pleasure and reward. (Source: http://science.howstuffworks.com/life/teenage-brain1.htm )Teens should have a second chance, if they mess up once, what makes you think they’ll mess up again? Teens shouldn’t be able to be tried as adults because they aren’t adults themselves, they shouldn’t go to jail for 25 to life. They should at least get the chance to work out their crime by doing community service, for example.

  • Just not mature enough yet!

    1. First of all, they aren't fully mature; their brains are still developing!
    2. They are still in high school...LEARNING.
    3. Being an adult means that you are capable of a lot more responsibility, such as:
    -having a job
    -being independent
    -paying bills etc.
    -caring for a family (if you choose to have one)
    4. Some say that teenagers have to get "insight" on what adults carry out in their daily lives, and that just proves that they're not adults since they are still learning!

  • They are teens, not adults!

    Teens are not adults and treating them as such is wrong. Frankly I think the age that people become adults should be raised, but that's another argument. Teens are not mature enough to be tried as adults. They are still learning how to become responsible mature people they are not yet adults.

  • Teens going to jail?

    They are just kids. They shouldn't have to go to jail. Teenagers will act irresponsibly until the age of 18. Sometimes adrenaline comes in and teens do stupid things. Haven't you ever done anything stupid when you were a kid. I cant imagine you were perfect. Nobody can expect for someone to be perfect either

  • I'm a teenager

    I've argued numerous times on this subject on this website and in class.

    The fact is a teenager is not an adult, we aren't treated as adults aren't given rights like an adult and are even looked down upon because we are not adults.

    Now that a teenager makes a mistake by commuting a crime such as murder stealing or selling drugs you people would like to treat us as adults. It's completely ridiculous.

  • No, teenagers should not be tried as adults.

    Trying teenagers as adults violates basic logic. Teenagers are not adults; therefore, they should not be tried as adults.

    The main reason prosecutors move to try teens as adults is to secure a harsher sentence. This is a symptom of a larger problem in that prisons do no treat and rehabilitate inmates.

  • There should be an age around 25 where they could be charged as adults

    18 is not an age where you would expect a kid to me most mature at. They should not be able to be charged as if they were adults. Teenage years are some of the most stressful times in a persons life and sometimes things can happen. I don't believe that we should be able to ruin a kids whole life for what they did in their teenage years.

  • Teens should not be looked at as an adult.

    Teenagers are not as mature at the ages 18 and down. Their mind is not well as developed as an adult's is and they can't wrap their minds around what they are doing. Most of them don't even know what they have done. Most teenagers don't know when they are doing something bad, they just go with it. Some of them go through family problems and they don't know what to do and just do violence.

  • Teenagers should not be tried as adults, however, there are alternatives

    Even though committing crimes such as murder, theft and any drug charges are against the law and teens know better, most are unaware of court proceedings and the legal system itself. The portion of the brain that makes decisions isn't even fully developed until the ages of 25-30. But this doesn't mean teens should get off the hook. Instead of trying them for life, those below 16 should be put in until 18 or before (depending on severity of the crime) but those above should serve longer punishments. No teen should be put in for life, I find that pointless. They should be given a second chance but there should still be justice and order when making the decision.

  • Juveniles should not be tried as an adult, because their brain is not fully developed.

    In often times juveniles have a hard time controlling their anger and emotions is because their brain has a hard time processing situations in which it takes mature brain to perform the correct decision. And most of the juveniles that commit a heinous crime later in life wake up and ask themselves what where they thinking. Why would they think so childish and why did they have to act on the first thought that came through their mind?


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
Anonymous says2013-02-17T02:25:37.690
If you compare to other corrupt governments then i think teens should be tried as adults.