Amazon.com Widgets
  • Give equal opportunities

    As in the olden days, lower castes were badly harassed and discriminated. To uplift the lower castes and give them equal opportunities reservations are must. Not even today u can find people in village getting enough food due to lack of education opportunities. To prove their their talent reservations are must.

  • Yes reservation should be there...

    Since India is a democratic country therefore, there should be equality among all and through reservation equality is maintained in our country as it gives chance to backward classes...And according to our constitution we all have same fundamental rights and one of fundamental right is right against exploitation and since these classes are unaware of it then how will they fight against it? Then anyone can exploit them...So, reservation should be there..

  • Yes Reservation should be there for few more years

    Upper casts has ruined SC/STs families over 2000 years , giving reservation for just 3 generations are not enough to conquer the loss they have faced over the years. They are still poor in majority and deserve chance to get educated. Reservation should be still given to them for few more generations to let them come on same social status as Brahmins.

  • It started well but rules needs to be amended

    I am sure most of us don't even know why reservation came into picture in the first place. We start questioning/cursing the system just because we are not directly getting benefited out of it. Was it given to the people randomly or on lottery basis, NO! It was given to those backward community who had no education, money, awareness etc.The country was not treating the backward community as equal. Unfortunately reservation was based on the caste system (and not on the economic conditions of the people) .It was easy at that point of time to recognize under privileged based on their castes(as most of these under privileged people belonged to some specific castes). In today's relevance one could question or argue over the caste as the sole factor to identify these people who are given reservations, but no one can deny that it has actually helped India in getting only better. Every system/ rule has its pros and cons, so has reservation system and it needs to updated to match the current scenario/perspective/needs.
    If a nation has to develop/prosper then it will have to take all of citizens forward, leaving a group of people behind wont help.

  • There must be reservation.

    There are still people in the backward community who have no education. The country is not treating the backward community as equally as we think it does. We must give them enough facilities so that they can develop and become equal to the forward class. After everyone is equal, reservation can be stopped, which would take at least 50 more years.

  • Reservations a Positive discrimination

    Reservations a considered a Positive discrimination. When there are two parties which are not equal then it is not fare to treat them equaly. The existing situation of inequality has to be removed first. How to do it? The most disadvantaged among the two has to be provided with a positively discriminated treatment so that they can make use of the opportunity to become equals. Hence Reservations in case of Sc/St and Women are inevitable for a rapidly developing nation like ours. Reservations reflect the principle of " EQUALITY" enshrined in the Constitution.
    When special coaching is provided for children who face difficulties in coping with fellow companions, why not reservations for the disadvantaged sections (SC/ST, Women) who have been deprived of opportunities for decades together?

  • Yes Reservation should be there for few more years

    Upper casts has ruined SC/STs families over 2000 years , giving reservation for just 3 generations are not enough to conquer the loss they have faced over the years. They are still poor in majority and deserve chance to get educated. Reservation should be still given to them for few more generations to let them come on same social status as Brahmins.

  • There should be reservation for sc st

    Most of the sc st (about 97%) who seems to be rich do not have any assets because there fathers belong to a very poor family and don't have any land house asset provided by there Grandfather. The only support they have is the job of there father. They always try to help there relatives because they can't see them in poor condition and send them money from there own salary. They never try to build there own asset in order to secure the future of there own children and they even don't have any savings in banks too. When these children grow up then they realise that if they didn't get any job then they have no other option to earn money. This makes a necessity of getting a job. This is the reason why all sc st whether from rich family or poor family should get reservation in order to secure there future. A candidate of sc or st only gets education and nothing else from his family. He/she is on his own to secure there own future. On the other hand a general candidate seems to be poor but they have lots of assets that are given by there forefathers.
    So please don't debate on this topic again.

  • Eradication of backwardness, poverty and living standard of tribes.

    Reservation helps to protect their rights which were lost in the history since Aryan invasion. By the help of reservation people of backward tribe will get equal status in the society. Reservation also helps in the development of the lower strata of the society, so it greatly influences the overall development of the country.

  • Yes, it should be.

    The base of reservation is not economic but socially, educationally backwardness. It clears the structure of hierarchy in the society which is so ridge that it can't be easily break even through economic status. So the purpose is clear to equalize the society.
    Second, you can't compare two unequal things with the same parameters. So before for fair competition equal merit should be there and these merits or talent also require some amount of cultural capital which comes through an inheritance. So economic status can' t be appropriate parameter until this huge gap is not fulfilled.
    It is not an overtake of 'meritorious' student, if they are really 'meritorious' they would be surely selected. Equality should be based on equal parameters, not one sided.

  • No reservation is required

    Since there is reservation the students who r not belonging to st sc category they get discourage when they score gud marks work hard but due to reservation the students who hav gt less marks than her gets that seat. And its very bad . Govt should make new scheme. Govt should do scheme in which students who r poor cant afford education should be provided with their all education fees irrespective of cast and all jobs and education seat should be given on marks which the person gets not on cast. Becz it is nt a case tht every higher cast person is rich and lower cast is poor. And after completing education and getting job compulsarly they should pay the govt money little by little. In this way every talented and the person who really deserves will get opportunity to prove them and no discrimination will happen everyone will get chance.

  • Reservations are fundamentally undemocratic.

    They were only meant to be there for the first 10 years of our country being established. It has been almost 70 years now, and the current situation is way worse: misuse and arbitrary usage of reservations has led to undeserving (and frankly) idiotic candidates getting seats at educational institutions and jobs they have not earned. They illegally take the seat of a more deserving candidate. Percentages of different classes are decided beforehand. What is uglier than that?

  • No reservation required , if it will be there after 10 years India will have a tough time

    As there will be huge gap of thought and jobless will be there from un reserved category and that time 3-4 th generation will be there fighting for jobs in unreserved category,
    I urge Indian govt to look in this matter on very serious note and give priority for jobs without any reservation

  • Enough is enough . 60 years of quota politics, and what more !!!

    Arbitrarily pushing incapable lots up for vote should be over. Only merit, merit and merit, nothing else should be taken into account. One caste INDIAN. Talent does not depend on money. Government support to education for all is the main thing that every backward people should get. There should not be any more push ups that is harmful to merit churning in our country.

  • Reservation is a keeper of caste divisions, make it more rationally based on Economic status

    70 years of reservation in itself is a proof of its utter failure and promotion of ineligibility and demerit. Have we not paid enough in the form of inefficiencies and in-competencies of people who are not the best choice to serve a post in administration of this Nation.

    MERIT needs to be promoted and not incompetency in the form of excuses that i am from backward caste and so i am being targeted, this has become a trick to not do your work and keep shouting unnecessarily.

  • Should be base on economic status.

    Reservations in india are based on caste system which give access to backward classes to education , jobs, health facilties.. But today these so called backward classes are much ahead of general category. They are the richer ones. They can themselves able to be in competition with upper classes. But when government provides them with more opportunities , it becomes a cherry on their cake. And as a result general category has to suffer. Reservations should be provided on the grounds of economic status so that the people who are poor get access to various opportunities. This would help to uplift thee poor people and also abolish the caste system which will automatically lead to development of our country.

  • Should be base on economic status.

    Reservations in india are based on caste system which give access to backward classes to education , jobs, health facilties.. But today these so called backward classes are much ahead of general category. They are the richer ones. They can themselves able to be in competition with upper classes. But when government provides them with more opportunities , it becomes a cherry on their cake. And as a result general category has to suffer. Reservations should be provided on the grounds of economic status so that the people who are poor get access to various opportunities. This would help to uplift thee poor people and also abolish the caste system which will automatically lead to development of our country.

  • No!!!! It is not right

    Everone has the right to sit anywhere they want and spend time with normal masses. There should be no reservations for sc and St classes.India is a republic country but still some people are closed inside 4 walls like this.This should not happen and the rule should be removed hereafter.......

  • No, it should not be

    Firstly, re-evaluation should be made over the reservation system whether it has benefited the backward classes & uplifted their social or economical status since the independence till now. Government should take a initiative to conduct the survey on this and accordingly a strategy, a plan should be design to make equality between the so-called high status people & low status people. Secondly, reservation in the promotion also should be re-evaluate, as because, it may be continue to benefit those who do not deserve for it or already on higher rank in Govt. Jobs. So the benefiting the cast basis, only to those who are already in system of benefit is no more to resolve the problem of upgrading the status of the people from lower social background. To conclude, rather than the reservation on cats basis it should be more on the basis of the socioeconomic status and should involve the free education, job opportunities, and identification of the talents from low social backgrounds.

  • One India one country one reservation that is only MERIT ...............!

    Now reservation in promotion – a new vote bank mantra and they justify why reservation in promotion is required. However all their justifications have no base and just for vote bank. Few of their justification our so called politicians claim “Many officers are not honest in their assessment of SC/ST people will be low graded and they see that no SC/ST people will be elevated to top post”, “Corruptions are more where SC/ST representation is less”, “Where SC/ST people are enjoying work atmosphere there is a best output and the results”, et all. However, I don’t agree with one of the justifications they do, it’s all for political parties own benefit.


Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.