Its not even a question! Jeff is just better. A better question would be is jeff overrated and the answer to that is yes. Thats my opinion though. Some people like this creepypasta. The most scary thing about this in my opinion is the picture anreven then the pic isn't that scary.
No brainer it would be Jeff The Killer, also, im ever sorry if you would choose Jane The Killer, but her back story isn't even that good, also her anger toward Jeff isn't even that solid, she hates him for killing her family, but at the same time she mimics him, I have a more reasons,just well yeah, I think that's enough until I get a reply.