The Instigator
Debate0ts
Pro (for)
Tied
0 Points
The Contender
Athias
Con (against)
Tied
0 Points

Death Note who is right Kira or L

Do you like this debate?NoYes+1
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: 7 Point
Started: 3/11/2019 Category: TV
Updated: 3 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 2,686 times Debate No: 120749
Debate Rounds (5)
Comments (21)
Votes (0)

 

Debate0ts

Pro

Which one of death Note character is right one

L or Kira
Which side u r?
Athias

Con

I'll take L's side. You can start.
Debate Round No. 1
Debate0ts

Pro

Welcome then
Myself Talach Sumer im a boy. Plz intorduce ur self also to counter my intro.

Let start then, Oh no my favourite is L.
I have total crush on this character.

But in debate i m taking Kira sides.
Kira is good, Intelligent and as a normal college kid. He just want to be crime less society. ! Criminal less society!
For that he take a hard action to banish such creatures by killing them with the help of death note.

He knows as his father in police that the legal procedure for justice is lame and not much effective to make his dream true.
He certainly make crime rate fall by killing. His action r just like god which stand againts for injustice. Even its way r bad but the changes in soceity r appreciate by many people even though they name him kira
God of justice
God of the new world.
His actions r for the creation of new good living crime less criminal less society only.
Athias

Con

My name is Athias; it's nice to make your acquaintance.

If I remember correctly, Light Yagamai a. K. A. Kira ("Killer") acquired the Death Note while he was still in high school--given that he became aware of "Ryuzaki" (a. K. A. "L") during his college entrance exams. By then, He had already murdered hundreds, Including FBI investigator Ray Penber and his fiance, Former FBI Investigator, Naomi, Who as far as my knowledge goes didn't commit any crimes. L also pointed out in one the earlier episodes of the series that Kira didn't kill just convicted criminals, But alleged criminals, Ex-convicts, And suspects in ongoing investigations.

Furthermore, Kira (Light Yagami) kills NPA Director, Takimura, Manipulates Rem into saving Misa by killing L, And seriously considered killing his own sister, Sayu, In his trade with Melo in order to throw off the investigation of the SPK. Kira's actions demonstrated not "justice" but a God complex and self-preservation. Kira was nothing more than a remorseless murderer, Willing to kill anyone--even those who were close to him--who got in his way.
Debate Round No. 2
Debate0ts

Pro

WELL I M quite impress from ur knowledge on subject. Its pretty good from me on the debate.
Its kind of i m facing some tough guy.

I m not saying that saying that Kira is innocent person at all. His hands r bloodiest from all other character in series.
But its initiative was simple that, Bad of worst guys need to be don't exits. But as he gain the power of death note he become ruthless, Kill anyone who threat to his dream. Even his intelligence is as super as L. He get its rival.
And the war started between kira vs L. And history taught us that every thing is fair in war. We just have to surpass our enemy no matter what it takes. That what kira do.
Kira killed those innocent people for only his self defence perspective. Not such as he motivated to kill criminals.
HE do really feel pain"bottom of the heart' for killing those people (ray penber, Naomi, L, His sister, His assiatants etc. . )
but he do that such a terrible thing to survive againts L.

but its quite on L side then,
L knows that Linda L Taylar was going to die. As tough is it good from legal side.

the death note corrupted the light yagami. After he give up the owner ship of book he just opposes the idealogy of KIRA also for a bit of time he on L side to find out the x kira.

its totally fault of that book and the shinigami riuk that's only wants entertainment.

AT the end of series
riuk words r just gives the sympathy to light yagami as a fare well and sorrow that he convert such innocent person wages to death end.

AT LAST THE FAULT IS IN THE POWER WHICH ITS GOES ITS CREATES MIND DISORDER just same happen to KIRA.
Athias

Con

"I m not saying that saying that Kira is innocent person at all. His hands r bloodiest from all other character in series. "

Then how can Kira be right?

"But its initiative was simple that, Bad of worst guys need to be don't exits. But as he gain the power of death note he become ruthless, Kill anyone who threat to his dream. "

So then, How can someone who's a ruthless and merciless killer be right?

"And the war started between kira vs L. And history taught us that every thing is fair in war. We just have to surpass our enemy no matter what it takes. That what kira do. "

The idiom, "all's fair in love and war, " doesn't apply here because it was the police vs Kira. Kira had followers, Yeah, But they were never organized nor trained in armed conflict. Furthermore, L didn't seek to kill Kira; he sought to capture Kira and hold him accountable for his crimes; Kira neither wanted to get caught nor answer for his crimes. He was evading the very "justice" for which he claimed he murdered.

"Kira killed those innocent people for only his self defence perspective. "

It wasn't self-defense. Neither Ray Penber, Nor his wife to be, Naomi, Initiated any form of violence or aggression toward him. And to make matters worse, Naomi, Was only investigating the death of her fiancee. And when Naomi was close to discovering the identity of Kira, Kira reveals himself to her (taunting her) just before he compels her to kill herself. Where is the "justice" in that?

What about his sister Sayu? She was only a hostage of Melo but he considered killing her because he didn't want SPK to discover that Kira had an attachment to Sayu Yagami. Where's the "self-defense" in that? That wasn't self-defense; that was self-preservation.

"HE do really feel pain"bottom of the heart' for killing those people (ray penber, Naomi, L, His sister, His assiatants etc. . )
but he do that such a terrible thing to survive againts L. "

Kira was without remorse. Even in the end of the series when his identity was finally discovered, He showed no remorse for his victims. He didn't even have remorse for his dead father when Matsuda brought up the subject. He showed no restraint in manipulating and killing his followers, Either (e. G. Kiyomi Takada. ) And was the least bit affected when learning of their deaths.

"but he do that such a terrible thing to survive againts L. "

So how does this make Kira right? How is he any different from any other criminal who's just trying to "survive" against the police?

"the death note corrupted the light yagami. After he give up the owner ship of book he just opposes the idealogy of KIRA also for a bit of time he on L side to find out the x kira. "

So if the Death Note corrupted Light Yagami, Then how can the product of the Death Note, Kira, Be just or right?

"AT LAST THE FAULT IS IN THE POWER WHICH ITS GOES ITS CREATES MIND DISORDER just same happen to KIRA. "

So once again, How is Kira right?
Debate Round No. 3
Debate0ts

Pro

Debate0ts forfeited this round.
Athias

Con

Athias forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 4
Debate0ts

Pro

Hey thanks for that day

we settle in round four that's good.
once again thanks for forfiting round four. I m totally out of mind yesterday.

but i post some small argues on that day in comment box. Plz check if u want.

I know that is not considerable argues. Its must be in the proper round not in comment box!

Lets start then,
Well i have less points and also favour to prove that Light was right.
i simply revel for u that" it's tough on kira side to argue with flawless"

On the starting scenario light only kills the criminals which deserve to die, Either by law or by him " which is right things"
but the L take this thing out of the box and made him kira. Which now both do right and bad things.
and the bad things for only his self defence.

On just when appearance of L
he challenge Light to kill him. Make him to, Take out his crazyness to became a ruthless person.

ON ur points of views, Its concluded that killing a person is not right either he is criminal or not.
Then L is also wrong as Kira. Because he let light to kill Linda L Taylor.

Actually L put his dummy to test light. Knowing that the cause of linda death. He knows it at all, Whats gone to happen.
But he just lay low and watch linda die.

And from this he challenge light, He creates rivals games along light to kill him he just tease him to be crazy and make some flaws.

but light yagami was intelligent. He over came all lines, Barrier that L establish to capture him. But here this action of L change the light into kira he does the killing thing as a game.

L only wants to capture Kira. BUT such a way he's using cause light to kira tranformation he make light to be panic on situtation but kira over this but he became ruthless.

It's all L treating ways of things that the rightness of light goes to self defence murder.

its started with linda taylor where L manupulates "creates rivalry" the condition of light to be bad person.

if L makes some other judgement at first then may be a chances that the light yagami would called by another name at the end "not by kira"

THAT'S ALL I GOT in these debate. Plz u have to square my points.
make A good stand for L.
My favourite.

but on end i say
the rightness of a things is not to be judge by how cruel, Or bad he is its needed to be noted that whats reasons behind it.
in my case Kira side his idea r good to create crime free society but the way he choose is bad
but he's action and ways r totally work in the series.
people r still confuse some to take a side in between L and KIRA.

MY DEBATE OVER now.
Athias

Con

Athias forfeited this round.
Debate Round No. 5
21 comments have been posted on this debate. Showing 1 through 10 records.
Posted by anc2006 3 years ago
anc2006
there is somebody named L in this site. Call him.
Posted by melcharaz 3 years ago
melcharaz
sorry about that. Mercy is selective by nature. Save "Some" for potential good.
Posted by melcharaz 3 years ago
melcharaz
in the sense of perfect justice, They were both wrong, In the sense of perfect mercy, They were both wrong. Justice would have said kill everyone for the potential evil
Mercy would have said save everyone for the potential good.

an intresting series however.
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
Plz post a comment in the round Athias

U have to make stand for what u choose

Atleast for L Sake
3 hours r left here
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
finally what a relief!

finally i successfully posted the final argue by my side.
i went this time through PC to post the my points.

thanks to all of u, To help me for such issue

i m very happy at last my argue post.
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
i not use any hyper link here nor any number in post but still not accepting the post
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
only 2000 words r posting
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
Hey thanks for that day

we settle in round four that's good.
once again thanks for forfiting round four. I m totally out of mind yesterday.

but i post some small argues on that day in comment box. Plz check if u want.

I know that is not considerable argues. Its must be in the proper round not in comment box!

Lets start then,
Well i have less points and also favour to prove that Light was right.
i simply revel for u that" it's tough on kira side to argue with flawless"

On the starting scenario light only kills the criminals which deserve to die, Either by law or by him " which is right things"
but the L take this thing out of the box and made him kira. Which now both do right and bad things.
and the bad things for only his self defence.

On just when appearance of L
he challenge Light to kill him. Make him to, Take out his crazyness to became a ruthless person.

ON ur points of views, Its concluded that killing a person is not right either he is criminal or not.
Then L is also wrong as Kira. Because he let light to kill Linda L Taylor.

Actually L put his dummy to test light. Knowing that the cause of linda death. He knows it at all, Whats gone to happen.
But he just lay low and watch linda die.

And from this he challenge light, He creates rivals games along light to kill him he just tease him to be crazy and make some flaws.

but light yagami was intelligent. He over came all lines, Barrier that L establish to capture him. But here this action of L change the light into kira he does the killing thing as a game.

L only wants to capture Kira. BUT such a way he's using cause light to kira tranformation he make light to be panic on situtation but kira over this but he became ruthless.

It's all L treating ways of things that the rightness of light goes to self defence murder.

its started with linda taylor where L manupulates "creates rivalry" the condition of light to be bad person.

if L makes some other judgement at first th
Posted by Leaning 3 years ago
Leaning
If a hyperlink is included don't include the hyperlink.
Posted by Debate0ts 3 years ago
Debate0ts
Oh god the comment is also not postting in here

And small one r acceptable to post here
No votes have been placed for this debate.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.