Baghdad once the center of learning, now thrown back to the stone age. Do you think it was politics (yes) or religion (no) that caused it?

Asked by: horvathda044
  • Politics has and will always be corrupted, religion knows some humanity.

    I agree that it has, not that my agreeing changes the facts or the numbers but I do. Has the way people practiced their religion changed in the city of Baghdad before and after the occupation, oh wait I meant the peaceful intrusion of the U.S army? Most likely not, perhaps people have slightly increased their faith in God to help them through these tough times. Has the politics in the city changed before and after the intrusion? Yes, yes it has. To be fair on you guys, I'll say it changed when the leaders lost their minds and started massacring everyone. You can argue that just like religion, politics does have an extreme side and a more modest one. But let's be realistic, the majority of political leaders are political extremists (i.E. Every president of every country in the world) while the majority of religious people practice their religion peacefully without crashing into towers in New York. Politics does have the upper hand on the way education is practiced in a country, religion sets expectations, politics attempts to reach them.

  • In this context it is impossible to split the two

    In Baghdad, how do you separate politics from religion? It is a religious dictatorship. So the only real answer is that it is both. Part of it is the split on how they interpret their religion, mixed with the power struggles in the area.

    You can make an argument as to which is the bigger influence on the current state, but to say that it is one or the other would be too black and white for the situation.

  • Religious caused intellectual thinking.

    I think Baghdad was known as the center of learning because of religion. Religion encouraged questioning and intellectual thinking. Furthermore, the questioning of religion did sprout the ideas of furthering knowledge. The main religion of that time frame did allow people to question its religion, and that is how people had become curious. I do believe political reasons do add to why it was once the center of learning, but religion was the major drive of it.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.