It begs the question. The presumption is that there are only 2 choices, and we are born one way or the other. It implies that something , a string of DNA or some cosmic force or whatever, compels us to be "good" or "bad" - highly subjective terms to begin with... Like any living thing we are bound by the desire to obtain enough energy (i.E. Food) to survive, not become an energy source (i.E. Food) for something else, and to reproduce. Infants express this very well, and cannot be attributed to "selfishness" because they simply have no sense of self; it is not until 18-36 months that humans recognize themselves in a mirror, start making the distinction between "me" and "them", and most importantly begin to understand that "them" does not feel exactly what "me" feels at the exact same time - terrible twos struggle to understand that not everyone else is hungry (or tired, or wants to play) exactly when and as much as they do. Once that is figured out, we develop a sense of empathy - and humans are not alone in this; there are many animals that develop a sense of community or family, collaboration, and ethics. These things do not have to be taught, they absolutely happen naturally. The supposed "good" and "bad" behaviors are taught in spite of this, not the other way around. The overlap is where we should focus, not the differences, when we try to determine better ways of behaving in ways that cause the least amount of suffering to others.
I think that everyone is born selfish and without morales. I think that the kids are taught to be good or bad. They usually turn out bad if they are neglected or if they are around bad behavior. They only learn to feel compassionate. So they need to be taught selflessness.
Trust but verify. We may not be inherently bad but we are inherently imperfect. Some live to exploit our weaknesses. That is bad. It is also rational. What it is not is innate. We are not innately rational. We are not innately bad. Rationality can be a good thing but we need to make it deliberately good.
Yes I believe that humans are inherently good. The world is made up of all kinds of people but generally the people you come across are good people with good intentions. I believe the majority of us come into this world without the thought of intentionally hurting someone else or being a menace. There are those who are born with traits that would on paper suggest that person is a bad person, however most people learn through experiences how to be bad and take advantage of people. If we weren't genuinely good on the inside from the start, I don't think our civilization would have made it this far.
I like to keep telling myself that the majority of humans are inherently good, but I always have to remind myself that there is bad in everyone. No one in this world is perfect and some people have more bad than others. Unfortunately, it is common to assume that people will do things to serve the self rather than the group and this is more often true rather than false. That's not to say that people aren't inherently good however. I believe when you see times of crisis the good is more likely to surface.
Yes, I think that I would call humans naturally good in nature, and only a few that are born more aggressive than others. Humans will generally rise to try to help others that are in trouble, and this shows that they are good. I think deep down we are all good.
Humans were born to satisfy themselves. If you gave one toy to two toddlers, chances are that the stronger one would get the toy, leaving the weaker one with nothing and crying. There is almost no chance of them sharing the toy unless the parents drilled the act of sharing into their minds, and this would be learned and not inherently.
Humans are not inherently good. If they were, then there would be no crime or ethical dilemmas. There would be no need for things such as the Ten Commandments. People have a balance of good and bad in them at all times. Unfortunately bad often wins over the better half of us.
Humans aren't inherently good. They aren't inherently bad either, but I think there is more bad than good when you look at us overall. Look how we live and treat each other. Look at how we treat the planet. Look at how we treat the animals. Look at all the wars we've waged.
We have to kill things just to get calories and remain alive. We also harvest by force the materials that rightfully belong to other life forms for basically everything. Our shelter, Our clothing, Etc.
Furthermore, We habitually harm the other humans in our lives, Even and perhaps especially the ones we most care about. We deceive, Take advantage, Form heirachies, And so forth. Even a well-meaning and totally ethical person can't escape this basic reality.
"Bad" might be an over-simplification, And these points don't negate the value we have and the positive things we are capable of, But they certainly aren't good. And to deny them involves a willful blindness that I at least find pretty inexcusable.
Perhaps "imperfect" would be a better term.
Employers, coworkers, family members, so-called friends - I’ve observed most are selfish, will lie to get an advantage, will take advantage of weakness, will hurt those closest to them. Knowledge is power so once they know your weaknesses, vices, fears, insecurities, then they will use that knowledge to emotionally blackmail, manipulate, extort, or betray for personal gain. The 20% or less are the children, the naive, the innocent fools who believe in inherent goodness. The 80% are the predatory who take advantage of the innocent or outsmart the other predators. 42 years old and I can’t count more than 2 in 10 (out of maybe 1000 close interactions, even 200 seems too high) that had integrity, loyalty, honor, decency, etc. When the cats away the mice will play. Employees steal time or money to be lazy or selfish. Spouses cheat because it’s easy to get away with it. Parents abuse because nothing there to them. Friends betray for personal gain. Employers lie to avoid accountability. Ever seen a customer correct a bill that’s too low by mistake? Ever seen the dropped cash returned to the owner? 2 in 10 at best. Humanity is evil by nature.
Without parental authority, a toddler will kick, taunt, and steal from other kids so they can feel better about a situation they're in. It's the parents drilling ideals and morals into the kids head that makes them second guess things before doing them. Without the parents, who's to say those kids won't go their whole lives doing the same exact things?