• Codetermination Is Socialism

    The country mandates that half of a board of directors for a company be elected by the workers. Workers getting a direct say in the economy is socialist idea. The government shouldn't be interfering with the way in which companies choose to manage themselves. A group of brilliant entrepreneurs shouldn't be forced to give half their company's management over to the workers. Negotiation with unions on pay and benefits is appropriate, but the union should not be dictating overall business policy and possibly ruining or stopping a great idea from getting passed.

  • Because it works

    When your definition of socialism is something that does not work it means that you are blind to what socialism means. Germany is the most socialist country on earth. The USSR was not socialist. They called themselves socialist, but they also called themselves democratic. The Nazis called them self socialist, and they weren't socialist either. Germany has employee and state representation on company boards, state owned railways, and State controlled banking.

  • Sounds a lot like Obamas America

    This is exactly what democrats here in the U.S. want, less freedom, more government control. The U.S. will definitely be this way before long. It's the European model in which the New World order is built upon. No guns, sex, money or freedoms. Certain democrats here in the U.S. are already lobbying to control every aspect of your life even down to what you eat, but hey it's ok in the U.S. to murder babies and sale their body parts.

  • Socialism Works Best

    Germany has high taxes, universal health care, universal college education, great infrastructure and government control of the banks. This is a socialist model with few problems. The corporate structure of having workers share control is beneficial because it promotes strategic buy-in to the mission and goals of the company. It also allows competitive advantage because profit can be wrapped back into the company rather than going to shareholders.

  • Germany is a socialist democratic dictatorship

    I am from Germany. And socialism in Germany is exactly the reason why I left.
    As a German citizen, you pay about 60% of you wages for taxes and social benefits. Even asylum seekers get the same money as a long term unemployed would. And that is a lot of money and additional benefits! For being lazy or lacking the courage to fight for his country.
    While I think the US has too little of a social net (we could use universal healthcare and free universities here), Germany has way too much. Somewhere in the middle would be perfect.
    And furthermore, Germans do not have freedom. If something you ar es doing annoys somebody, even if his annoyance is totally unfounded, the German regime will create a law against it sooner or later. It is an unfree society of rude and envious people.

  • If Obama had turned USA into Germany

    There is no doubt that Republicans would be calling him a radical communist. Nevermind just socialist.

    Germany has many state-owned and/or regulated businesses, and the workers have many protections. Generally, Republicans dont like admitting that its a socialist country, because they want to pretend that all socialist countries are failures. But the basic fact is that Germany is an American liberal's wet dream, and that it is to left of Bernie Sanders. If you dont want to call that socialism, then you cant call any liberal socialist either. So takes your pick.

  • It feels socialist

    We see a Country with a governmental (means: socialist) pension system, a governmental healthcare system, a governmental education system, with a labor market which is captivated by labor unions and government, a confiscatory tax system, a national quota of more than 50% with a heavily regulated housing market, a massively subsidized and regulated agricultural sector and an energy sector which is embedded in a complicated mesh between market and state with at least a hundred thousand businesses in municipal ownership (i.E. State property)

  • Socialism is not communism!

    Socialism allows for privately owned property and businesses exisitng alongside public run institutions. German is the perfect example. It has a coordinated market economy. Essentially the core of socialism is the redistributive capactiy of its welfare state and strength of employment restrictiveness policies. Jeremy Corbyn, in the UK is advocating far less in terms of redistribution and is named a hard core communist. This is a perfect case of labels not always matching the actual policies involved!

  • No; the economy is dominated by private enterprises that operate in a market economy.

    Capitalism is defined as an ECONOMIC system where the means of production are privately owned, where a distinction exists between owners who live off profit ("capitalists") and the mass of the population who work for wages or salaries ("workers"). Socialism, by contrast, is defined as an ECONOMIC system where the means of production are collectively owned, either by the state or collectively so there are no "capitalists" (all the workers are collective owners of industries). Germany is a purely capitalist economy, but has stronger social welfare policies and social benefits for its population than the United States affords its citizens, which Americans tend to confuse with socialism. Social welfare is an entirely different thing from the technical definition of socialism.

  • Basically Capitalism with a few government regulations.

    The government does not prevail; for it simply establishes programs for the country's good, with their country's people paying for it (the taxes do not affect them greatly). With this form of government, Germany is the most economically powerful country in Europe, with unemployment rate at only about 5 percent.

  • Germany is not a socialist country, but like all western democracies, it's got some programs that are socialist.

    Above all else, socialism is characterized by government ownership of the means of production. That's what REAL socialism is. Look at the list of private German companies that thrive in the world market - drug companies, telecoms, airlines, car companies - and it's clear that Germany is a capitalist country. An example of government ownership of the means of production would be the health care system in the U.K., which is comprised largely of government employees and government owned and operated hospitals. Contrast that with Germany's system that relies on doctors in private practice.
    But in addition to the "government-owned-means-of-production", there is also a redistributionist element to socialism. Government funded health insurance for the majority of Germans is a socialist safety net. So is the public school system in the U.S. In that sense, all western democracies have some socialist tendencies, but they are, by and large, capitalist societies.

  • What is Germany then?

    If Germany is not a Socialist country, then what is it? Their borders are tightly controlled: No goods from China and pockets of minorities such as African-Americans, Latino, Asian communities are NON-existent. These minorities which work in service oriented industries are NOT present in Germany. Germans do it all. Outsiders are not welcomed. Dollar stores piled high with goods from China, like we have here in the U.S.? Non-existent in Germany. Germans manufacture their clothing and their dishes! Capitalism encourages entrepreneurs and excellent customer service; but unless you are German, the stops put in place by the German government are absolutely prohibitive if you are NOT German. Capitalism and customer service go hand in hand. And customer service is not a German philosophy. Germany does business like the 1970's: slow and inconvenient! Yet, customer service is one of the best and biggest aspects of capitalism and competition. The German government monitors, dictates, and is involved in the day-to-day decisions of its citizens lives: from how many cell phones, computers, tablets, and televisions each family has and how many they can have, with exorbitant taxes if you surpass the "limit" (which families must report the number of electronics and the government does not "believe" electronics for each family member is necessary) to strict censorship of books and countless music video's. Freedoms are limited. But if you are German and have never known anything different, you might not think so. I do know: I lived in Stuttgart from 2005-2014 and I am not German, but a 10th generation American. And, no,, if you are a tourist for 2, 3, or 4 days does NOT count. Being a tourist is impossible to discover what living in Germany is all about. Limited freedoms? Interference in the smallest aspects of citizens' lives? Censorship? No understanding of customer service and little or NO diversity in Germany's population? No competition and no new idea's welcomed or allowed? If heavy government control and limitations are set upon its citizens, if that is a measure by which we define Socialism, then Germany very easily fits that definition.

  • Germany is a Social Market Economy

    Germany has a capitalist market economy, however, with relatively high tax rates. This money is used to fund extensive social welfare and health care programs, as well as anti-unemployment measures and a mostly state-run system of education. Most government owned corporations where privatized since the 1980's, the others face private-sector competition, and operate mostly without state funding.

  • Germany is a not Socialist country

    No. The country is somewhat socialist, it uses mostly capitalism, similar to WWII United States. Even though the rest of Europe is considered socialist, Germany does not fall in that realm. Small uses of the socialist tactics are evident such as the workers nominating or electing the board of director for a company, but again this is just a small part of the running of Germany.

  • Americans mix socialism with social state.

    Americans have this great problem. Mixing socialism with Social state/social welfare. It's not the same. Socialism doesn't have free trade and is a closed market, it's very close to communism. Social state (which is what exists in majority in Europe) is a different story. It has free market, capitalist economy only that it has social welfare programes. Do you think a socialist country (Cuba, ex-Yougoslavia, Libiya, etc.) produce a Mercedes? Or BMW? There you go.

  • Germany Is Not a Socialist Country

    Despite what some may argue is a strong social involvement by the “workers” within the German economic system, the underlying principles behind their economic structure are capitalistic. Socialism is a true form of economic structure, and Germany does not meet the requirements set forth in the definition of such an economic framework, to be considered even close. Just because they have common health care, among other useful things, that are not yet evident in the United States, many want to label Germany as “socialistic” in theory, only to support their own derogatory agendas.

  • To some extent, but they mostly use the capitalism that America used around WWII.

    After WWII, both Germany and Japan were in a terrible state. America helped them out with supplies, etc. And in doing so, they also showed the two countries how using Capitalism the way that they were would help the economy (coincidence that they're 2 of the best countries in the world, eh?). They do have some socialist aspects, but for the most part, they cannot be considered a socialist country like the rest of Europe is.

  • No, they use their government for the best interests of all their people but they all prosper.

    They certainly seem socialist in that they support prosperity and security for all of their people, not just the rich upper-class as you see in notably capitalistic countries. However, my understanding of the difference is that socialists don't own anything or make money for themselves and this is not the case in Germany. Suggestions of socialism bring up national, political biases; Americans are generally given to believe that socialism is wrong but in researching this question I've found that Germans seem to have an American dream of equality and security.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.