Legalization of adult incest: Is incest consistent with the family unit?

  • God's law is the wisest law.

    Just because two adults consent to an incestuous relationship,
    it doesn’t make it right. God, with his
    limitless wisdom, outlawed incest. This
    was not only because many underage children are victimized. It was also because incest is disgusting. With all of the eligible mates available in
    the world, why would someone want to date a family member?

  • Adult consensual incest can benefit some families.

    With the use of contraception incest is good. It has brought me and my sister alot closer. We used to argue alot and didn't get on very well, Which effected the family. We spoke about how we could get along better and I told her I read that sex between a brother and sister can be very bonding, So we have been having sex and it has been amazing! It has helped us alot.

  • Incest is good

    I believe incest is consistent with the family unit because it creates such a stronge bond between family members. I'm not saying everybody should do it but it can have a positive affect on some families. As long as the family members are adults, On birth control and its consensual then its good.

  • Incest is bad for the family unit for several reasons.

    First a family born out of incest increases the rate of birth defects and mental retardation. This gets worse with time if there is a tradition of incest. If your parents are cousins whose parents were cousins and marry your own cousin, well that's going to lead to a very unhealthy (biologically speaking) offspring. This can be seen in small communities that only marry within their community even if the don't marry family directly. :

    Also most types of inbreeding usually are due to an unhealthy relationship within a family. Cousin-Cousin marriage isn't as bad as parent-child or sibling relationships biologically but it leads to peculiar societal traits. In countries that practice this as well as FBD or Father's Brother's Daughter marriages there is a behavioral tendency to become "clanish." Like Afghanistan or Scotland used to be before modern times. This leads to corruption and a lot of fighting with none-relatives. Often women are mistreated in these societies.

    In the single one off cases it is often an inappropriate relationship between an older relative taking advantage of a younger one, so there is always a power imbalance in the relationship.

    So in short don't do it! It harms your family or the family that results from it. We have a mechanism where we do not find people we grow up with attractive as a barrier to incestual relationships.

    I meant to thumb down but I hope my point comes across. DON"T DO IT!!!!


  • No incest is not consistent

    No, I do not think that adult incest is consistent with the family unit and should always be banned. I think that adult incest, or incest at any age, destroys the family unit and creates a biological structure that just isn't right. At any age and any time in life incest should be banned.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.