No contest. Tiger wins. Sorry Cougar.
Tigers are so much stronger
Tiger is too powerful for a puma (mountain lion). When even lions have failed miserably against the mighty tiger, what do you expect from a puma?
They're too big to fight a mountain lion
What a silly comparison is this ! An average bengal tiger can scratch down to tore up the African lion easily, then what is PUMA or Mountain lion which also do not graduate as big cat. Simply tiger is mighty and so agile that can end up PUMA's life in single paw move.
Puma for the win.
Pumas are better, but in this fight they are totally out classed
I have to really admit the Puma (Mountain Lion) would win. Because you never know they could just jump on the tiger scratch his or hers face over and over again so sorry tiger Puma (Mountain Lion) would win!