Atlantis: The Lost Empire
Lyle Tiberius Rourke is dead! Iron Giant is better.
This vote makes no sense because I've only seen the Iron Giant.
Are you kidding?
The iron giant was just better in general to put it shortly. To extend far beyond what I should Would be this. First off Animation. Animation is so much higher quality in the Iron Giant the combination of 3D and 2D is amazing. At the time this was very difficult to pull of. It was a risky type of animation to pull off. Now for Atlantis's it was fairly average. It had some good shots underwater but it wasn't amazing. Now Voice acting. Both movies were fairly average nothing amazing on either side. Now for the story. The Iron Giant invented the plot of a big scar looking creature actually being friendly being attacked by the military. The only thing that came before this was ET but this has a much more sad amazing touch to it. I will say Atlantis had a good story it was decent but they executed it pretty poorly now for music. Just personal opinion I think Atlantis's was better. Iron giant just idnt stick out to me. Overall they are both good movies I just think Iron giant is better