Should schools have more leeway in expelling students in order to curb school violence?

  • The "well-being" of one student should not trump the welfare of the rest of the students and staff.

    I am a teacher in a district that has no alternative ed. I'm forced to teach a psychopath who has physically battered other students at school, Made extreme verbal threats to end other students' lives, Threatened to sexually assault staff, And even brought a knife to school in elementary, Which he used to try to stab other random kids "to kill them" on the playground (whereupon he had to be removed from the playground by police). Lately, He has taken his predatory behavior to a new low by assaulting and bullying cognitively impaired students because they are "easy" targets. Like his mother and other relatives, The only time that he makes any attempt to behave is when he is on probation in between stints in the corrections system. This kid is a ticking time bomb and students/staff are genuinely afraid of him to the point that some have left the district because of the threat that he poses. Even though admin can see the writing on the wall, They claim that their hands are tied; we can't identify the kid as emotionally impaired because we can't prove that his emotional state is not the product of the extremely dysfunctional environment that CPS has allowed him to remain in for over a decade. I don't think my district will take this issue seriously until this time bomb goes off and a body count has to be taken.

  • Yes, they should.

    Obviously this is a power that can be abused (but really, any power can be abused). There are drug addicts and students who come to cause disorder and trouble, and interrupt the educational process.

    Troublemaking students should be expelled but not on the first count (unless it is serious enough). That is my two cents.

  • Yes, I think schools should have been leeway in expelling students.

    I think that if a school administration feels that a student is posing a threat to the safety of another student or staff member then they should have the authority to be able to suspend or expel that student, a school should be a place where everyone feels safe and those who try to disrupt that peace must be dealt with.

  • No, more leeway in expelling students would not curb school violence

    Expelling students is not the answer to curbing school violence. When a student is expelled from school, he (or she) falls farther and farther behind in his work, which only makes him more trouble when he returns. A better option is alternative classrooms, where students are sent when they cannot make it in their regular classrooms. In the alternative classrooms, students are led to figure out why they are having difficulty, what can be done about it, and then helped to fix the problem. Many students have been helped with this type of approach when, had they been simply expelled, they might have eventually dropped out and perhaps never have lived up to their potential. Expelling students and sending them home is rarely a good alternative. Many times the home is the reason for the problems the student is having in the first place. Schools need to be places where even the bad kids get a chance to improve.

  • No They Shouldn't

    I do not believe schools should have more leeway in expelling students in order to curb school violence. Schools already have quite a bit of power when it comes to expelling students, however they are in place to provide an education and that can't be done when the student isn't in class. Schools need to handle the problems and study ways to better handle them. They shouldn't just guess an action will work and try it with massive failure.

  • Expulsion is not the remedy.

    No, schools do not need more leeway in expelling. When you expel a student, they then have nothing to do but get in more trouble. We need to move away from the "expulsion" mind set because it serves no purpose - all you're doing is moving the violence from the school to the street.

  • No, I don't think so.

    I think there are many ways to curb school violence, but expulsion should only be a choice if it happens frequently with one student. I think better environments need to be created in these schools, so children can thrive and violence is at the back of their minds, if anywhere at all.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.