Should the citizenship question be included in the census?

  • YES why are we still talking about this ?

    Is this really a question. I am sorry but why are we still talking about this? And the People in office are not holding up to there Oat of Office by letting the illegals stay and take part in the census. It distorts district lines . And how are the illegals allowed to get a drivers license. They are by definition illegal and are already breaking the law. If I break the law there are punishments or disciplinary action taken against me. What are theirs ? One last thing. We have a hard enough time helping everyone here at home , why dont we fix some of our own issues before trying to help others who most just want a free ride that we Tax payers have to pay for. I would rather that go to the vets or homeless. Anyone but someone who knowingly breaks the law and then expects us to put up with it

  • Why so some want to count every type of "something" a person in the U.S. can be but not how many are actual citizens?

    Should we not know the number of U.S citizens as well as non-citizens that inhabit out sovereign? Some want to count all sorts of "differences" ostensibly to help people for perceived disadvantages. So why might they not want to know who is and isn't a citizen? Voting power, I think.

  • The citizenship question should be included in the census because it is a valuable piece of demographic data.

    There is a lot of policy surrounding illegal immigration these days, and an accurate estimate of the number of people in the United States who are and who are not citizens would be valuable for creating and refining these policies. Without these counts, it is hard to know how much money should be allocated certain ways.

    Posted by: babyuniqh
  • The citizenship question should be included in the census, because the government needs to know how many citizens it has.

    There is a difference between a U.S. citizen and someone who just lives in the U.S. If the government starts treating anyone who is in the U.S. the same way that they treat citizens, then our nation becomes meaningless. The U.S. government, therefore, needs to know who is a citizen and who is not.

    Posted by: 5h4yGust
  • The question of citizenship should absolutely be included in the census, because we need to know how many illegals there are.

    It is bad enough, in this country, that we have to worry about illegal immigrants abusing our system, but for them to not be counted is wrong. We have a right to know how many, and even who, in this country, are not citizens. It not only impacts the economy and job market, but also has a drastic impact on our national security.

    Posted by: ObedientMervin
  • Yes, because people should have to be citizens to be counted in the census.

    The census is supposed to be counting and tracking information on the people who live in the United States. Tracking those who are not even supposed to be living here is a waste, and throws off numbers. Keep the numbers aimed towards the people who legally live here.

    Posted by: HealthyMose59
  • It is fair for our government to ask anyone for their legal status in the United States, so it should be included.

    I do not understand why anyone should be offended to show their citizenship to their country. It is a completely fair question to ask. Honestly, I do not see how it would help very much because people who break the law very well may lie or simply not fill out a census form. There is no harm done in putting this question on the form, though.

    Posted by: DizzyCasey
  • I feel that a citizenship question should be presented during the census, because it will reflect the number of people who are actually allowed to vote and are likely to be permanent residents, as people who are here for other reasons are not residents.

    There are over 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States. These people are not residents who are able to vote and, because the redistricting of district lines will occur after the census has been taken, the added numbers of illegal immigrants who cannot vote will cause the lines to be redrawn based on illegal immigration, not on how many citizens are present.

    Posted by: R4yAnych
  • Citizenship questions should be included in the census, because census information is used to determine many important programs.

    Citizenship questions should be included in the census, because census information is used to determine many important programs. Districts for the United States House of Representatives are allocated by population. It is grossly unfair for native-born Americans and naturalized Americans to be denied their right to vote, because illegal aliens are present in another location.

    Posted by: JamieM
  • It is important to know who in the US is or is not a citizen.

    The census is conducted to measure the amount of people in each area. If someone is not a citizen in this country it needs to be known so we can keep an accurate count. It will also help us to identify where the biggest immigration problems in our country are located. It is an absolutely necessary question in my opinion.

    Posted by: 54l3mGrand
  • Asking the citizenship question on the census form will give non-citizen respondents no choice but to lie on the form, thus providing us with nothing but misinformation.

    We should not ask the citizenship question on census forms. The census form is not meant to be a check on the legality of the immigration status of respondents. It is meant to be a process to keep track of data on the types of citizens currently inhabiting our country, and not their legal status. That is the job of the INS. The obvious flaw in this proposal is that respondents who are here illegally will have one of three choices. (1) lie, say they are citizens, fill in the form and return it, providing inaccurate information, which defeats the purpose of the census-taking. (2) don't fill out the form, throw it away, and thus also defeating the purpose of the census-taking. (3) tell the truth, send the form in, and hope that the Census Bureau is not sharing information with the INS, who may now come knocking at their door. I doubt that very many illegal immigrants will choose "door number 3". It is unfortunate that, after talking about the immigration problem for decades, this is the best "solution" we have been able to come up with. This is what happens when we have too many politicians and too few statesmen.

    Posted by: CI3Iike
  • No, because I don't see where it would make a difference.

    What would be the point of asking about citizenship on the census? The purpose of the census is to account for the individuals whom reside in this country and allocate resources appropriately. (At least, that's what they tell us.) Whether someone is a citizen, or not, does not change the fact that they are on American soil and utilize the resources in their community. Also, asking a citizenship question would scare away those who participate in the census based on the fact that they are assured of that citizenship doesn't matter when filling it out.

    Posted by: MohaI0v35
  • I don't believe the citizenship question should be included in the census because it is a waste of time.

    It would be great if we could get a count of the total number of illegal aliens residing in the US. However, it is unlikely that an illegal alien would answer this question honestly, and it would further burden and slow down the census taking to try to determine the accuracy of the census reports.

    In addition, my understanding is that one of the purposes of the census is to allocate federal funds for services to local populations based on the number of people they have. At the current time, hospitals, schools, fire departments, and clinics have to provide services for all residents, even those that are illegal. Therefore, funds need to be allocated for all residents. Therefore, this question is unnecessary.

    Posted by: IindsM3II0w
  • The Constitution requires a census, but not that citizenship be stated.

    The 2010 Census left the citizenship question out for good reason. It is unconstitutional, for one thing. US Census Bureau recognizes this fact, stating it is "...required by the U.S. Constitution to count everyone in this country, regardless of immigration or citizenship status." This is a good thing; asking citizenship would encourage some immigrants not to answer, and this would undercut needed money for state services that will inevitably pay for immigrant services either way.

    Posted by: NoIanMu5ic

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
No comments yet.