"buy one get one free" is one free or two for half price?

Posted by: Heterodox

Comment with your reasoning.

Vote
25 Total Votes
1

One is free.

13 votes
0 comments
2

Two for half price.

12 votes
0 comments
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
BrendanD19 says2016-02-12T02:03:05.3121475Z
My mind is blown!
Black-Jesus says2016-02-12T02:08:22.3817223Z
It depends... Are you taxed for both? If you aren't then I would favor the argument that it is one full price and one for free, but if you are then I could see the point of those that say it is two for half price.
Bob13 says2016-02-12T02:35:35.5405912Z
@Black-Jesus In Wisconsin, you are taxed for both. https://www.revenue.wi.gov/taxpro/news/2011/111208.html
Bob13 says2016-02-12T02:36:36.5993826Z
I'll see if I can find anything for other states.
Black-Jesus says2016-02-12T02:52:26.4738715Z
You don't need to, it isn't that big of a deal
triangle.128k says2016-02-12T03:22:25.8834103Z
Wow, the polls finally work again.
TBR says2016-02-12T07:27:14.2349350Z
Its marketing only.
Heterodox says2016-02-12T12:59:16.5211274Z
Well, a lot of people seem think they should be getting things for "free". I don't think they actually realize that most stuff isn't free, it's usually paid for (by raising taxes on everyone). Oh, and I think it's two for half price, because the free one is conditional on the purchase of the non-free one.
Diqiucun_Cunmin says2016-02-12T14:20:03.3629967Z
In Hong Kong, a parent quarreled with a teacher over this because the teacher marked his child wrong for the 'one is free' interpretation.
Diqiucun_Cunmin says2016-02-12T14:21:41.3160246Z
Anyway, the 'two for half price' interpretation is obvious if you consider the situation as an implementation of second-degree price discrimination.
Fabrice says2016-02-20T22:58:59.6477408Z
One is free. You can't buy only one for the half price.
DjKagamine says2016-05-27T07:40:43.1374804Z
You are still buying 1 product for it's full price, Only after doing so you recieve another one for 'free'. You can't just buy 1 for half price

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.