[ Star Wars ] Is the Confederacy of Independent Systems Better Than The Republic?

Posted by: Knaveslayer99

I wanted to debate this before but my opponent ended up just never debating me so I'll ask on the question here on the Polls.

  • Yes!

  • No!

22% 2 votes
78% 7 votes
  • You may have electricity but there's a reason you're jacking your fighters and tech from the Jedi, ti's because you're incapable of invention and your brains are furthermore held back by lust of power. Control first thyself, then thy people and then the universe; ensure it is in that order or you shall never prosper for long.

  • The Republic was bad a*s! Seriously, they managed to govern an entire galaxy. Besides, the clones are the coolest soldiers in Star Wars.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
Knaveslayer99 says2016-10-21T00:44:32.3631223Z
@BlargArgNarg They did not govern the entire galaxy as many worlds were criminal controlled or neutral. Also Droids are far better than Clones the clones can barely take down Jedi meanwhile Magma Guards and Commando Droids were capturing Jedi on a daily basis. Also it was the Republic that started the War to begin with.
Kirigaya-Kazuto says2016-10-21T02:24:07.2319804Z
Neither are inherently better than the other. Especially considering the Republic, technically speaking turned into the empire.
Knaveslayer99 says2016-10-21T02:54:20.1352015Z
@Kirigaya-Kazuto True but I find that the Republic has done more horrible things than the C.I.S let alone the C.I.S's ideology was about creating equality due to the Republic's corruption.
Vaarka says2016-10-21T15:19:45.9937749Z
@Knaveslayer99 - Actually, most of the droids that were produced were foot soldiers, usually the yellow/brown and dark grey ones, as they were cheaper to make than commando droids and droidekas and whatnot. However, these droids often worked as a dependent machine that was simply told "shoot them", and would advance via overwhelming the enemy. The clones, on the other hand, are independent. While they still take orders, they move on their own accord, and were trained for combat.
Knaveslayer99 says2016-10-21T16:15:52.4641547Z
@Vaarka I am more than aware of that and the only reason they were not mass produced [ Commandos and such ] was simply because Sidious wouldn't allow it even Grievous states that the B1 Battledroids are a worse threat to them than the clones.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.