I'm a huge Legend of Zelda and a huge LOTR fan. I feel Aragorn would win this one though.
Chased off a gang of immortal Nazgul with a fiery stick, pretty ballsey after all :p
Well, I mean he's only defeated a man three times his size like...13 times!
Aragorn would attack Link. Link would the run way. Link would then talk to his fairies. They would tell him about this long quest to get every item that Aragorn is weak to and many side quest to gain more health. Link would return kick Aragorn but with his fairies telling how to beat Aragorn. Link is used to taking out bad guys like Sauron alone.