Can doctors withhold information about a pregnancy to avoid an abortion?

Posted by: Charliecdubs

Here's a scenario; a doctor finds out the baby will have a severe birth defect and knows that the parents will have an abortion if they find out. The doctor is anti-abortion and does not want to tell the parents what will happen. Does the doctor have the right to not tell the parents? What do you think?

  • Yes he is saving a life

  • No, the parents have every right to know what their baby will be like

14% 3 votes
86% 18 votes
  • The Doctor has a professional occupation which requires them to be completely open with the people involved. He/she has no right to withhold information based on personal opinion.

    Posted by: RossM
  • That goes against the hippocratic

  • Quite obvious.

    Posted by: L.D
  • It is the doctor's job to tell the parents. He is not supposed to withhold information, otherwise he is to be fired. Besides, it is the woman's choice to have an abortion or not, not that doctor's.

    Posted by: SNP1
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
discomfiting says2014-04-21T13:40:02.6342909-05:00
discomfiting says2014-04-21T13:42:50.0808004-05:00
Most doctors won't without any information from their patients despite their personal opinions. They hold the hippocratic close to them in the practice of medicine; it's like a sacred text.
ESocialBookworm says2014-04-21T16:11:44.7011670-05:00
The question should be rephrased, "should..."
discomfiting says2014-04-22T08:17:20.6869517-05:00
Can they, yes, legally they can. Ethnically, no they should not.
RossM says2014-04-22T08:41:48.9683834-05:00
I don't believe that it is within the law to do that. One can decide not to tell the parents, just as one can decide to take someone else's life. That does not mean the law supports it.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.