Do humans have free will, or is every action dependent on a chemical build up that determines the action before hand?

Posted by: Mikal

Determinism

Vote
39 Total Votes
1

Everyone has free will

20 votes
3 comments
2

No one has free will essentially. Our actions are predetermined by chemicals and wiring. (Determinism)

19 votes
5 comments
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
MassiveDump says2013-09-10T18:08:32.8105661-05:00
Oh that's some crazy sauce D:
Magic8000 says2013-09-19T21:22:24.9699247-05:00
The 2 comments in support of free will commit the fallacy of appealing to consequences.
Magic8000 says2013-09-19T21:27:02.7358357-05:00
Murderers and rapists may not have the free will to do otherwise, but we should still put them in prison, just like we keep a lion in a cage. The lion doesn't know why, he's just acting by his instincts. A compatibilist approach could have moral responsibility and have deterministic ideas about murderers. I don't subscribe to compatibilism, but it doesn't mean you must believe in free will because you don't think determinism cuts it.
DavidCarter says2014-01-14T12:32:07.0221034-06:00
Where's the compatibilism position?
augustberkshire says2014-04-22T00:22:29.9238634-05:00
The universe operates mostly by determinism, a chain of cause and effect that we can't break into with an uncaused cause, so there can be no free will. The parts of the universe that are random or indeterminate are, by definition, not within our control either, so there is still no free will. The only "proof" of free will that proponents can offer is that it is "obvious," forgetting how easy it is for us to be fooled.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.